New Shared links now take you directly to the source!

Learn more

All links shared by fellow members now take you directly to the source. Click on a video, something to do or a yellow comments icon and you’ll stay on GOOD.is. Living well and doing good just got faster!

Questions? help@goodinc.com

Close message

Close message

Phillipe Copeland

I am an author, educator, and world changer.

I am good at helping people fight for their preferred futures and teaching others how to do so.

Location
Boston, MA
Website
copelandblog.com

Activity

  • Phillipe Copeland replied to a comment by smw907

    Why America Needs Another Kind of Justice via magazine.good.is

    8

    Tags

    smw9079 months ago

    Phillipe - I think the idea of "justice" brings along with it the idea that a universal right or wrong will be reached. Our laws and court system are the closest thing we have to achieving that. However, the idea of real restorative healing (or accountability, outcomes), and when it would be obtained, would be up to the parties involved. I do wonder how a model like that could be managed but realize it could be a powerful way to compliment our justice system. Lastly, I had a strong reaction to this because I believe the lines of justice (defined by our laws/courts) and a sort of personal justice have been blurred with this case. Thank you for your thoughtful feedback!

    Phillipe Copeland9 months ago

    thank you. i consider myself a student of these issues and no expert. I appreciate your generosity in sharing your thoughts. "Compliment" is a good word and is what I'm encouraging people to consider. There are things that retributive justice approaches can do and things they can't do. I look forward to learning more about what possibilities might come with restorative justice as a compliment to retributive justice. Also as you suggest, definitions of justice vary considerably across cultures, religions, and ideologies. One person's justice is another's injustice.

    Join the discussion

  • Phillipe Copeland replied to a comment by John Wynn

    Why America Needs Another Kind of Justice via magazine.good.is

    8

    Tags

    John Wynn9 months ago

    Perhaps I am naive as well, but I find the civility inherent in restorative justice far more beneficial to society as a whole than punishment alone.

    Phillipe Copeland9 months ago

    Thanks John, I would agree. The key word is "alone". Right now we are using a primarily punishment alone approach to crime which has demonstrated that it has limitations. Why not try something different? People are already doing it and learning a great deal.

    Join the discussion

  • Phillipe Copeland replied to a comment by smw907

    Why America Needs Another Kind of Justice via magazine.good.is

    8

    Tags

    smw9079 months ago

    Let me first clarify. I appreciate your perspective very much. I also strongly support more healthy, positive approaches to dealing (and healing) with violence and the tragic unraveling that always follows. I have dedicated much of my life to this pursuit. And, I've been inspired by the idea of Ubuntu for many years. To answer your questions: I do believe in finding better outcomes to preventing violence and helping us embrace our community;value life and inspire others to value life as well. So, on those points I agree and applaud. I don't believe the outcomes of our Justice System always represent "justice" to everyone. In this particular case, based on our justice system, justice was served. It's the idea of intertwining the word "justice" into your conversation of healing, restoring (or preventing) I don't support. Regarding the rest of my comments. I should clarify.They have more to do with the public debate and less to do with your op-ed. I'm dismayed by the angry dialogue our community (on both sides) has had in the name of justice (or finding justice). And the call to change our justice system because some were not happy with the verdict, not because the due process failed. But yes, let's please continue the conversation on prevention, respect and more positive ways to restore community.

    Phillipe Copeland9 months ago

    Thank you this was very helpful. Could you say more about your objection to intertwining the word justice into discussions of healing, restoring, and so on. Those who support restorative justice would appear to make such a intertwining. What is is about that you are objecting to? Also, I agree with you that from a retributive justice standpoint, justice was served. My point is that that approach to justice can do some things that have value but not everything.

    Join the discussion

  • Phillipe Copeland replied to a comment by smw907

    Why America Needs Another Kind of Justice via magazine.good.is

    8

    Tags

    smw9079 months ago

    The idea of justice is subjective. It is often coerced to fit the narrow definitions we, a group or others may feel is right. And often irresponsibly used to further a cause, idea or movement. Justice is not perfect and will never be. However, we live in a country that has the most civilized justice system in the world. Is it perfect, no. Does it provide an equitable opportunity for both sides to prove their case - ABSOLUTELY. I'm disappointed by the vast ignorance in our "open-minded", free thinking community, that is so blinded by their own personal beliefs, and cringe to think of the uncivilized form of justice that would exist if we were to indulge in this naive way of thinking.

    Phillipe Copeland9 months ago

    Thanks for taking the time to respond. I guess my point is whether or not justice is simply providing an equitable opportunity for two sides to prove their case. Is that really the best we can do? Why do you believe that the outcome of such a process represents justice? What exactly makes that any more "civilized" than other approaches? Who said anything about "perfection". It's a question of considering alternatives that might be conducive to outcomes beyond "proving" a case as you put it. Why is that naive?

    Join the discussion

  • Phillipe Copeland shared a link

    Why America Needs Another Kind of Justice via magazine.good.is

    8

    Tags

  • Phillipe Copeland replied to a comment by Paul Chenoweth

    Juneteenth Celebrates Emancipation, But More Black Men Are Incarcerated Than Were Enslaved via magazine.good.is

    13

    Tags

    Paul Chenoweth10 months ago

    I would also guess that emancipated Africans from 1865 would be surprised that the number of whites imprisoned and executed in this era exceeds the number of blacks. Census data seems to support that:
    Execution data: http://www.census.gov/compendia/statab/2012/tables/12s0352.pdf
    Racial Composition: http://www.census.gov/compendia/statab/2012/tables/12s0349.pdf

    Certainly, there are serious issues with the justice and incarceration system that impact black Americans (and perhaps at a higher percentage than whites). But aren't those same civil liberties (voting particularly) denied white felons?

    Phillipe Copeland10 months ago

    Paul, before I respond I don't want to assume too much about the point you are making. Could you say a little more about the meaning you are ascribing to the information you've shared?

    Join the discussion

  • Phillipe Copeland shared a link

    Juneteenth Celebrates Emancipation, But More Black Men Are Incarcerated Than Were Enslaved via magazine.good.is

    13

    Tags

  • Phillipe Copeland shared a link

    The Perils and Possibilities of an America Without Affirmative Action via magazine.good.is

    1

    Tags

  • Phillipe Copeland is now following…