Iranian Soccer Players: Banned for Life
- Posted by: Patrick James
- on June 23, 2009 at 4:33 pm
It seems that the Iranian soccer (or, football, as it were) players who wore green armbands as a gesture of solidarity with the nation’s protesters during a televised match against South Korea in Seoul have been banned from playing soccer in the country. For life. Their names are Ali Karimi, 31, Mehdi Mahdavikia, 32, Hosein Ka’abi, 24 and Vahid Hashemian, 32, and Iran’s pro-government newspaper reported that they have all “retired.”
Granted, in terms of graveness, this doesn’t really compare to what’s actually going on in Tehran and other parts of Iran. However, as Matthew Yglesias points out, it’s not insignificant. And it’s certainly telling. He writes:
…a dictatorial regime that prefers to stay in power through “soft” methods can use the threat of destroying people’s careers. Instead of being put on trial and executed, becoming a martyr for the cause, you can just be rendered unemployable in the field of your choice in a decision nobody has to publicly defend but everyone understands. You become, then, not an imprisoned hero, but perhaps just an apparently pathetic person … a cautionary tale rather than an inspirational example.
What’s funny is that these guys are, presumably, three of the 10 or 20 best soccer players in Iran, which means that they’ll need to be replaced with players of lesser ability, which means that Iran will fare less well in international competition, which means the nation will seem weaker, which could ultimately be a bitter pill for the hard-line administration to swallow.
Any soccer fans out there want to weigh in on where they’ll end up playing?








DISCUSSION: 4 Comments
Our government should offer them a spot on our national team. It should be our number one foreign policy objective…and hopefully it will make our team better. How pissed would that make the Iranian government?
Yeah, I think the way the Iranian government was forced to handicap its own team in order to maintain the false appearance of a united front is emblematic of the price of this kind of authoritarianism in general. You end up with weaker teams/results.
To the community of Good readers, how does this compare with the 1968 Olympic gesture? http://www.smh.com.au/olympics/articles/2004/06/18/1089484304254.html
These guys should be able to be freelance players and play for any country they choose.Why go back to Iran unless they know how to get a new election started which right now seems very doubtful.The Shah (dictator) has been the person pulling all the strings in Iran for a very long time and making things worse and people have known it but had done nothing about it until recently.The Shah told people stay home or else and we all know what that means especially after an innocent girl Neda was sniped awhile after he said this.If the people can’t get a new election,maybe those who want freedom should just leave Iran and those left can try to keep their economy afloat.The thugs will be the largest majority left and the only thing they know how to do is beat women and torture men.Good luck keeping the economy going in Iran if those are the only people you have left.