More Students Should Participate in Teacher Hiring

How does a principal really know if a teacher is a good fit for a school unless she gets feedback from students?

How does a principal really know whether a teacher is a good fit for a school and its students unless she gets feedback from the kids? In far too many school districts, particularly low income ones, teachers are still assigned to schools by a central office. Sometimes not even the principal, let alone students, has the opportunity to meet a teacher before the start of the school year. In other cases, principals meet candidates in large hiring fairs. Administrators often—especially if it's a candidate for a high need math or science position—offer a promising prospect a job on the spot. If they have the time, they get the teacher to come to the school to be interviewed by other staff or parents.

Over the past couple of years a handful of school districts across the country have made headlines for considering student feedback when formally evaluating teachers. While the practice isn't without controversy and needs to be honed—5-year-olds obviously lack the maturity to officially rate an adult—perhaps students should become a formal part of the teacher hiring process.

That doesn't mean allowing students to ask a prospective teacher random, inappropriate questions like those that emerged from a 2010 U.K. dust-up where it was revealed that students were asking candidates questions like "If you could be on Britain's Got Talent, what would your talent be?" To avoid that sort of ridiculousness, students have to be involved in an age appropriate, well-structured, and professional manner.

For example, last week I got a call from my 8-year-old son's elementary school asking if he'd be available to participate in the interview of a prospective teacher. The next day he sat in a room with the principal, several of the school's teachers, and a few other students as the candidate did a demonstration lesson. He and the other students participated in the lesson, which enabled the school staff to see how the candidate interacted with the kids.

Afterwards, the candidate left the room and the principal and teachers asked the students specific questions—whether they felt the candidate checked to see if they understood what she was teaching and if they felt comfortable asking questions during the lesson. This is appropriate participation for an 8-year-old—no need to grill one of their future teachers on her education philosophy.

I shared the experince on Twitter, posting, "This morn my 3rd grader participated in interviews for a new teacher at his school. More schools should have kids ask ?'s/give feedback." Indeed, while there are some schools, like San Diego's High Tech High, that are well known for having a teacher hiring process that includes students, the rarity of student involvement in the teacher hiring process was evident from replies from educators like 6Percenter who wrote, "Wow Liz that is fantastic. I've been teaching for 24 years & that NEVER happened."

The irony is that while there's plenty of big talk about running education like a business—no top notch corporate CEO could be hired by just sitting across from a single shareholder at a hiring fair—we don't allow teachers, the same courtesy. Although kids are not widgets to be counted and measured. They are "shareholders" in our schools. We should treat them that way.

Photo via (cc) Flickr user bpsusf


Some beauty pageants, like the Miss America competition, have done away with the swimsuit portions of the competitions, thus dipping their toes in the 21st century. Other aspects of beauty pageants remain stuck in the 1950s, and we're not even talking about the whole "judging women mostly on their looks" thing. One beauty pageant winner was disqualified for being a mom, as if you can't be beautiful after you've had a kid. Now she's trying to get the Miss World competition to update their rules.

Veronika Didusenko won the Miss Ukraine pageant in 2018. After four days, she was disqualified because pageant officials found out she was a mom to 5-year-old son Alex, and had been married. Didusenko said she had been aware of Miss World's rule barring mother from competing, but was encouraged to compete anyways by pageant organizers.

Keep Reading Show less

One mystery in our universe is a step closer to being solved. NASA's Parker Solar Probe launched last year to help scientists understand the sun. Now, it has returned its first findings. Four papers were published in the journal Nature detailing the findings of Parker's first two flybys. It's one small step for a solar probe, one giant leap for mankind.

It is astounding that we've advanced to the point where we've managed to build a probe capable of flying within 15 million miles from the surface of the sun, but here we are. Parker can withstand temperatures of up to 2,500 degrees Fahrenheit and travels at 430,000 miles per hour. It's the fastest human-made vehicle, and no other human-made object has been so close to the sun.

Keep Reading Show less
via Sportstreambest / Flickr

Since the mid '90s the phrase "God Forgives, Brothers Don't" has been part of the U.S. Military Academy at West Point's football team's lexicon.

Over the past few years, the team has taken the field flying a black skull-and-crossbones flag with an acronym for the phrase, "GFBD" on the skull's upper lip. Supporters of the team also use it on social media as #GFBD.

Keep Reading Show less