Research suggests high schoolers do better when schools start later in the morning, so why aren’t more districts pushing daily start times back?
Millions of high-schoolers are fighting with their alarm clocks through another academic year. As they struggle to get up early, parents battle to get them out of bed and off to school — a stressful way to start the day for everyone involved.
Are teenagers just being lazy when they have to be dragged out of bed in the morning?
According to the National Sleep Foundation, the sleep requirement for teenagers is eight to 10 hours per night. Yet, the average teen in America obtains less than seven hours of sleep on a school night. A big part of the reason why is that nearly half of all high schools in the U.S. start before 8:00 a.m. and over 85% are starting before 8:30 a.m.
Sleep deprivation in teenagers as a result of early school hours has been a topic of concern and debate for over two decades. Districts across the country have wrestled with the question of whether their high schools should start later.
I’ve been studying the effects of later high school start times for 20 years. My research shows that teens’ inability to get out of bed before 8 a.m. has serious consequences for learning and health outcomes. Essentially, the adolescent inability to be fully awake before then is a matter of human biology — not a matter of attitude.
Gotta get to class
In the earliest days of American education, students of all ages attended a single school, with a single starting time. In fact, as late as 1910, half of all children attended one-room schools. As schools and districts grew in size in the early 1930s, staggered starting times became increasingly common. The oldest students in cities and large towns were given the earliest starting time, with the thought that high school was preparation for the adult world of work. Many rural schools continue to have only a single starting time, as buses pick up students of all ages on a single run.
Since 2014, however, major national health organizations have taken a policy stand to support the implementation of later starting times for high school. The American Academy of Pediatrics, the American Medical Association, the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, and most recently, the American Academy of Sleep Medicine have all come out with statements that recommend high schools start at 8:30 a.m. or later.
A national conference held in April 2017 showcased the research linking teen sleep, later high school start times, and significantly positive academic, health, and safety outcomes.
Since the experts have started to weigh in, hundreds of schools in 45 states across the country have been able to make the shift. In fact, the state of California is currently considering a bill that would require all middle and high schools in the state to start school no earlier than 8:30 a.m. by the year 2020. Legislators are starting to consider teens’ sleep deficit an issue of public health.
[quote position="left" is_quote="true"]Teens’ inability to get out of bed before 8 a.m. has serious consequences for learning and health outcomes. [/quote]
Why does it matter if teens are tired?
Studies on sleep in general, and sleep among teens in particular, have revealed the serious negative consequences caused by lack of adequate sleep. Teens who are sleep-deprived — defined as obtaining less than eight hours per night — are significantly more likely to use cigarettes, drugs, and alcohol.
The incidence of depression among teens significantly rises with less than nine hours of sleep. Around half of teens who sleep four hours or less per night feel sad and hopeless, compared to just 19% of their well-rested peers. Teen car crashes, the primary cause of death for teenagers, significantly decline when teens obtain more than eight hours of sleep per night.
A newly released report by the RAND Corporation quantified the “costs” to our society of early high school start times in terms of lost income due to impaired academic and professional performance and car crashes for teens who are sleep-deprived. The report projected annual gains to the U.S. economy of nearly $9.4 billion over 15 years if high schools nationwide started at 8:30 a.m.
Biology of the teenage brain
So what exactly is going on with teenagers and their sleep patterns? Can’t they just go to bed earlier?
Research informing expert recommendations began in the 1980s, with studies that cast new light on what goes on in the teenage brain.
Brains release the sleep hormone melatonin as a signal that allows us to fall and stay asleep. In preteens and adults, the secretion of melatonin is flexible and variable, and sleep timing preferences are genetically based. But the timing is different in teens because it’s related to puberty.
For virtually all adolescents, the secretion of melatonin doesn’t begin until about 10:45 p.m. and continues until about 8 a.m. This means that most teenagers are unable to fall asleep until melatonin secretion begins, and it’s hard to wake up until the melatonin secretion stops. This fixed pattern of melatonin secretion in teens changes back to an individual’s genetically preferred sleep/wake timing once puberty is over.
I have interviewed hundreds of teens who all said that if they went to bed early, they were unable to fall asleep — they just stare at the ceiling until sleep sets in around 11 p.m.
In other words, the biology of the teenage brain is in direct conflict with school schedules, which typically require adolescents to begin school earlier and younger children to start later.
Desert Rose Adult High School students show Assistant Secretary Brenda Dann-Messier parts of a dissected worm. Photo via U.S. Department of Education/Flickr.
What happens with a later start?
Results from schools that switched to a later start time are encouraging. The students do in fact get more sleep, tending to go to bed at the same time but getting to rise a bit later in the morning. Not only do the teens’ use of drugs, cigarettes, and alcohol decline, their academic performance improves significantly with a later start time.
Most recently, car crash rates for teen drivers have declined with the implementation of a later high school start time. In fact, the crash rate for teens in Jackson Hole, Wyoming, in 2013 dropped by 70% in the first year the district adopted a later high school start.
Issues such as changing transportation routes and altering the timing for other grade levels often head the list of factors making the later start difficult. Schools also must consider the effects on after-school sports and activities.
Such concerns are valid. However, schools delaying start times have found creative solutions. For example, schools adopted mixed-age busing, coordinated with public transport systems, and expanded after-school child care.
There’s clearly more that needs to be addressed in making the change. But, in the end, communities that value maximum development for all children should also be willing to grapple with solutions.
After all, our children’s ability to move into healthy adult lives tomorrow depends on what we as adults are deciding for them today.