Poverty Porn and A New Way to Regard Social Impact

“Regarding Humanity” creates a space for learning and commenting on poverty porn and issues of representation.

A camera pans onto a young black girl from a perspective slightly above her. She stands alone in a field in an unnamed, unidentifiable location, looking away with a forlorn look on her face, never meeting the camera’s gaze. The voiceover: “This is Daniella. She’s nine. And her body is racked with pain from parasites; the same kind that killed her sister. Without help, Daniella could be next.” A single tear falls down Daniella’s face, as she now sits in a concrete doorway with no door, looking down.

This is a segment of an aid organization’s 2010 commercial that still runs on television and on various web channels. It’s the kind of advertising that we in North America have grown up seeing every night, the Sally Struthers-type infomercial that sold poverty, a cultural signifier of doing good, but also of being righteous and allaying latent guilt brought on by the spectrum of western history from colonialism to corporate greed. It is what we now are calling “poverty porn” in some circles, and simply bad aid in others.

The website Unite for Sight defines poverty porn as “words and images that elicit an emotional response by their sheer shock value. Images like starving, skeletal children covered in flies…” that exploit “the poor’s condition in order to generate the necessary sympathy for selling newspapers or increasing charitable donations or support for a given cause.”

The use of media, film, and design has burgeoned in the social impact fields. There are numerous examples of effective, innovative uses of image to communicate or drive social impact—which should be encouraged and built into program design. But there are just as many ways poverty porn has increased and morphed into new forms of manipulation.

So in today’s social impact landscape, what is poverty porn? It could be: Photos of rape victims in the Congo used to raise funds in annual reports. Images of squatting South Asian women looking up at Western aid workers. The “bad black man” trope reinforcing the “savior complex.” Short films featuring emaciated children lying in the rubble after Haiti’s earthquake. “Darfur for Dummies.” Celebrities, DIY activists, or NGO marketing departments creating photo opportunities with children swarming at their knees, saying the experience has changed their own lives. Initiatives that seek donations of used underwear to send to Africa. “Clitor-aid.”

How do we know it when we see it? The use of media, image, and design in any social impact field is of course dependent on context. It isn’t simply about the image—which in and of itself may be innocuous, or in a different context, realistic or even powerful. Images and media sink to the level of manipulation depending on what they are used for, and how they are shaped and placed. Understanding how to see propaganda and instead create initiatives grounded in respect with an attention to complex realities requires critical thinking and an educated eye.

And how do we know poverty porn is a bad thing, ultimately? There is power in engaging westerners through a language that we know, through tropes we are used to, through allowing us to feel good about the work we do—and when done well, it’s both good business and good storytelling. But as Unite for Sight says, “in addition to violating privacy and human rights, poverty porn is damaging to those it is trying to aid because it evokes the idea that the poor are helpless and incapable of helping themselves, thereby cultivating a culture of paternalism.”

Keep Reading Show less

How Storytelling Can Address the Complex and Intertwining Issues of Modern Society

Societal issues are complex and systemic and intertwine with each other. Answers can never be either/or.

“The power of storytelling is exactly this: to bridge the gaps where everything else has crumbled.”—Paulo Coelho

Keep Reading Show less

As Ed-Tech Advances, Technology Shouldn't Come First, the Learner Should

Successful and powerful ed-tech involves making the tech as invisible as we can to educators and students, even as it becomes more ubiquitous.

As the pace of technological progress increases, we need to realize that effective learning experiences have little to do with the tech behind them. It doesn’t matter, for instance, that Apple is selling more than a million iPads to U.S. schools every quarter, or that Microsoft 365 and Google Apps continue to make inroads into the schools. All of these tools—and more—are there to help increase student achievement and learning.
Yes, we have more platforms, devices, web 2.0 tools, applications, and resources than ever before, but if you are paying all—or most—of your attention to the tools, then you are misguided. As school districts continue to pour money into ed-tech, and as we hear the battle cry of teachers needing more ed-tech PD—ENOUGH! My work in transmedia has taught me that successful and powerful ed-tech involves making the tech as invisible as we can to educators and students, even as it becomes more ubiquitous. Technology should not come first, the learner should.
The real aim of ed-tech is to modernize pedagogy and to shape the education of the future. To achieve this, we must focus not merely on the tools available to us, but rather on shaping that future for education through the seamless integration of these tools into meaningful learning. Only with this focus will learning become so pervasive that the learning becomes indistinguishable from the totality of a learner’s life.
The interactivity and connectivity that ed-tech provides brings learning to life by maximizing engagement, stimulating learners’ minds, and allowing learning to grow organically. Striving to make the ed-tech invisible will allow learners, and content, to flow from one platform-to-platform creating a global interconnectivity that allows for genuinely collaborative sharing and the proliferation of knowledge.
If we use ed tech correctly, we will be able to focus on the problems that we have to solve, the opportunities that we hope to grasp. The future isn’t just something that happens; it is ours to build, learner-by-learner, lesson-by-lesson, here and now.
\nThis is part of a series of posts examining the idea time and imagining our collective future. Go here to tell us your wish for the future and we'll bury it in a time capsule.\n

Above illustration by Tyler Hoehne

Keep Reading Show less