This summer, as I listened to the unbridled joy of children playing outside my window, I read a New York Times article about first graders being placed in “Gift of Time” summer schools. For nearly 12 percent of first graders in East Ramapo, New York, summer break means being held back and receiving a “gift” of tutoring, with an extra order of tutoring on the side. Somehow, we are to believe that this will help slower children catch up.Except they can’t catch up. When they return to school in the fall, according to the Times article, they’ll be segregated in their own small classes made up of other kids deemed “low-performers.” At an age when children should be falling in love with learning, these children will be labeled, shamed, and tracked. Such practices have been discredited by a substantial body of research (if not common sense) and yet more and more schools across the country are implementing similarly punitive practices. Schools are seeing recess eliminated, electives are being cut, and teachers are insulted by the prospect of having their career and income threatened by their students’ scores on a single multiple-choice test. All in the name of No Child Left Behind, a mathematically impossible piece of federal education legislation, which requires all of the nation’s schoolchildren to be above the mean on standardized tests by 2014.Our schools may very well be in crisis, but not for the reasons bandied about in the press. The crisis is not based on teacher pay, lack of accountability, or a lack of rigor. The problem is that we do not create productive contexts for learning in which the needs of each child are met as their talent, interest, curiosity, and passion are amplified. The last thing we need is another sweeping top-down reform. In fact, it is my belief that the dominant solution to any educational challenge will be wrong and make the problem worse.The tragedy of No Child Left Behind, and the private and public efforts to undo its damage, is that not every child is given the chance to achieve her full potential in a caring, creative, dynamic, and intellectually rich environment. And in the absence of ongoing classroom innovation and grassroots advocacy, NCLB has taken over.These days, anyone who attended school is an expert in education and everybody has a plan to “fix” the public schools-the philanthropist, the businessman, the bureaucrat, the politician. For ages, business leaders and politicians have wanted to privatize the entire system and let the marketplace sort things out-as it did with Enron, Chinese pet food, or oil prices. Now, they’re taking control of schools through philanthropy. Parents of means, meanwhile, are opting out in record numbers, sending their children to private schools, or charter schools, or are homeschooling them. Indeed, as the federal government has steadily eroded public support for the public school system, through propaganda and failed policies, children are the collateral victims. The winners of the school wars remain uncertain; the losers can be found in almost any classroom.Of course, none of this is altogether new. People have been trying to fix schools for as long as schools have existed, but the tone shifted in 1983, when the Reagan administration published “A Nation at Risk: The Imperative for Educational Reform.” The report began with alarming rhetoric not heard since Sputnik: “The educational foundations of our society are presently being eroded by a rising tide of mediocrity that threatens our very future as a Nation and a people.””A Nation at Risk,” which claimed that educational issues presented a threat to our very freedom, changed the tenor of educational discourse. “If an unfriendly foreign power had attempted to impose on America the mediocre educational performance that exists today,” the report said, “we might well have viewed it as an act of war.” For an administration committed to eliminating the Department of Education, these predictions of an imminent apocalypse were the tool of choice to reshape the educational system.But it wasn’t until the first President Bush that the government made a serious push for help from the private sector. Bush thought business leaders might be able to help fix public schools by running them more like businesses. So in 1989, he asked the Business Roundtable (300 CEOs and governors) to try to reform education, since governors and CEOs-administrators all-share similar temperaments and a desire to impose top-down policies. Armed with corporate war chests and support from governors, the Roundtable’s influence met little resistance.Uninterested in the complexities associated with teaching and learning, the Business Roundtable demanded that state legislatures impose “outcome-based education,” “high expectations for all children,” “rewards and penalties for individual schools,” and “greater school-based decision making.” In order to enforce and measure these voluminous imperatives, standardized testing would be required. It sounds familiar now-these are the core tenets of NCLB-but at the time, the idea of applying the rules of business and competition to education was relatively new.These efforts fuelled the higher-standards movement. It’s hard to argue against raising educational standards, but imposing uniform curricula and teaching practices leads to a paradoxical lowering of standards.The Business Roundtable continued thinking about education through Clinton’s two terms-eight years during which nothing lasting changed the course of education reform-until today. Even though the public has lost some interest in buying what they were peddling, the damage wrought by the Roundtable persisted: Standards, and the measuring of standards, ruled all.

Quote:
It is my belief that the dominant solution to any educational challenge will be wrong and make the problem worse.

Rod Paige, George W. Bush’s first Secretary of Education, took his post after being the superintendent of the Houston Independent School District, where he presided over the “Houston Miracle” in the 1990s. Paige, who wrote his doctoral thesis on the reaction time of offensive linemen in football, was responsible for a remarkable increase in student test scores and a substantial reduction in the dropout rate across the Houston schools. Except that the test scores were cooked and the dropout reduction was the result of at-risk students disappearing from his district like Brazilian street children.The Houston Miracle soon became the model for the massive, standards-based No Child Left Behind Act, enacted in 2001. NCLB represented the most radical federal education initiative in history, passing easily in Congress with bipartisan support. Even today, both presumptive presidential candidates intend to keep the law in place, albeit with amendments.As it stands, NCLB requires continuous improvement in academic achievement. At-risk children failing to make adequate progress are subjected to an extra helping of the very same instruction that has already proven ineffective. Electives are taken away, while teachers in “low-performing” schools are given scripted curricula with ambitious titles like “Success for All!” A teacher in Miami might be greeted by a lesson in mid-November that requires them to read, “Brrr! It’s cold outside today. I wonder what the temperature is? Maybe it will snow.” But nothing is more central to NCLB than standardized tests.When most of us were children, we took standardized tests once a year for a few half days. The tests were a temporary distraction intended to offer one indicator of progress or aptitude. A teacher’s reputation or salary was not at risk; administrators didn’t feel compelled to cheat; and third graders certainly didn’t vomit on the test booklet. (Some NCLB tests actually come with instructions for what to do when a student hurls on a test.) When a child comes home from school, parents don’t ask, “Which quartile toward annual yearly progress were you in?” They ask, “What did you do today?” Since knowledge is a consequence of experience, it’s critical that children be engaged in learning activities that nurture their soul, expand their interests, build upon personal talents, and challenge their thinking. But today’s standardized tests-proudly called “high-stakes” by their proponents-trump all else. The theory behind the tests seems to be analogous to the theory that taking a sick patient’s temperature every seven minutes will cure him.Students in some cities and states can spend months each year engaged in test-taking. That does not include the incessant preparation for those tests. Just a few years ago, policy leaders would say, “Don’t teach to the test,” since it makes the results less valid and detracts from the richness of classroom activity. All of that has changed. Today politicians are unapologetic when they say, “Of course you should teach to the test! How else are you going to raise test scores?”It has long been said that voters hate Congress, but like their own representative. The same is true for schools. Parents hate schools, but they love their child’s school. This affection for neighborhood schools may help explain why previous efforts to revolutionize public education have failed: People felt that in general something needed to be done, but their schools were doing just fine.But NCLB’s shame, blame, and name-calling, accompanied by a steady stream of negative media accounts, miserable children, and low test scores, may finally push parents past the breaking point. A loving parent cannot help but be concerned by constant, very public reports of their children failing and their school underperforming. Perhaps the singular accomplishment of NCLB is the erosion of community support for public education. If parents do not trust their school, they are likely to withdraw their support and seek private alternatives. And that’s exactly what they’re doing. Homeschooling and private-school enrollment are on the rise; there are more charter schools than ever. And when that many people withdraw from thinking about and participating in the school, things go downhill even more quickly.With the business community, politicians, and parents hysterical about public schools, the conditions are right for something really big to happen. But major changes in schooling are costly and require bold leadership. A bake sale isn’t going to do the job. And so, over the past decade, two billionaires have stepped onto the scene. Taking it upon themselves to rescue public schools from teachers, administrators, parents, organized labor, and even democracy itself, Bill Gates and Eli Broad are turning public-primarily urban-education upside down.The philanthropic work of the Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation in the areas of health, education, and poverty is well documented, and Bill Gates’s generosity is unprecedented. The foundation’s well-intentioned investments in public education have not been particularly destructive or effective. Although they have spent more than a billion dollars to date on school-reform initiatives, the foundation’s grants-given to wildly conflicting models of education and primarily focused on making schools smaller-have been met with mixed success.More intimate schools with smaller class sizes are good for kids, who get more attention from teachers, form closer social bonds, and don’t get lost in the crowd. However, you cannot change just one variable in a system this complex and expect total transformation. Also, despite the enormous benefits of small schools, there are consequences as well. It may be impossible to maintain electives, extracurricular activities, sports, or student diversity in small schools. A 2006 Business Week article detailed how a Denver high school known for its award-winning choir crumbled when students were dispersed to three different “small” schools within the building. Surely, the program could have been preserved even when the school was divided, but the Gates Foundation says it doesn’t like to meddle. Additional focus and oversight by the foundation might ensure that the public schools to which it grants money actually improve.

Quote:
It’s hard to argue against raising educational standards, but imposing uniform curricula and teaching practices leads to a paradoxical lowering of standards.

Eli Broad, a Los Angeles billionaire, is another kind of philanthropist. Broad funds a narrower range of interventions and has demonstrated less willingness to experiment than Gates. Broad’s efforts advance a very specific model: top-down school management based on business principles. Over the first five years, Broad has committed over $500 million to his notions of school reform. He even runs an academy that trains school leaders in precisely this kind of management.Broad’s money supports more standardized testing, a longer school day, scripted curricula, merit pay, the replacement of school administrators with managers, support of charter schools, and mayoral control. In Broad’s worldview, incentives drive everything, including education. The annual Broad Prize for Urban Education gives a total of $1 million dollars to five urban school districts that do the most to raise student test scores. The award also grants college scholarships to students in the district. That sort of money and the press it attracts has a domino effect: All of a sudden, others want to get tough and adhere to the Broad manifesto, too.In 2002, Mayor Michael Bloomberg and his newly appointed schools chancellor, Joel Klein, seized control of New York City’s public schools, disbanding local school boards and reducing community involvement. Under Klein and Bloomberg, test scores may have risen, but chaos has ensued as the organizational structure of the district changes continuously. Now, policies similar to Broad’s educational blueprint are being followed in the city’s public schools. Last year, New York City earned the coveted Broad Prize.Broad and his followers also embrace charter schools. Charters are quasi-public schools that receive public funding but don’t have to play by the same rules; they have more latitude than public schools, including the freedom to use different curricula, employ non-credentialed educators, change the school calendar, ban unions, and be selective in student enrollment. In some cities, affluent parents use the charter laws to create private schools with public money. In others, like the New City Schools in Long Beach, California, innovative educators with a coherent vision of edu-cation teach in ways they believe will benefit children in their community.It is natural for parents to want the best for their children. Unfortunately, the charter laws may create greater educational inequity-rich, involved parents get their kids into the best charter schools, leaving only the poor students behind in the slowly deserted public schools. This forced choice could be avoided if every school was shaped by its teachers, parents, and community, with all children free to attend the school best-suited to their needs or interests. For example, the Montclair, New Jersey, public schools have experienced decades of success with mandatory school choice. Each elementary school is distinct and parents are required to choose the best option for their child.Broad recently gave a total of $23.3 million to two charter-school umbrella groups, the Knowledge Is Power Program and Aspire, to open 17 new charter schools in Los Angeles this fall. KIPP is known for its uniforms, longer days and school year, Saturday sessions, strict rules, and lots of homework. Supporters hail this formula as a boon to Angelenos, citing the schools’ remarkable success at raising test scores. Critics, meanwhile, fear that students who don’t get with the program quickly enough will vanish. Regard-less of whether these schools offer solutions to the challenges of urban education or not, opening so many of them so quickly may be considered reckless and surely dispenses with public involvement.In a new twist on the public-charter debate, Broad and his colleagues have also convinced school districts to hand over public schools to private or nonprofit charter-management companies. These companies are given the use of public facilities and get to run what are essentially private schools in them. That not only removes a public resource from the community, but also gives a handful of charter providers a hefty advantage over the community-based charters. With a little imagination, it’s easy to guess where this is headed.Traditionally, corporate philanthropy in education consisted of a speaker on career day or sponsorship of a softball team. I’m all for generosity, but I’m also for accountability. And I wonder, to whom are the Gateses and the Broads of the world accountable? They were not elected or even appointed, but their money is changing the ways public schools operate. They may do this for altruistic reasons, but what is a citizen’s recourse if their ideology harms children? And, worse, what happens if a billionaire finally throws up his or her hands and publicly exclaims, “Even I can’t fix the public schools”? Our schools may not be able to survive the sudden cash withdrawal-or the backlash.One way to navigate this new era of “giving” is by asking a simple question: Would these folks send their own children or grandchildren to their “reinvented” schools? Is a steady diet of memorization, work sheets, and testing the sort of education the children they love receive? Of course not. If affluent children enjoy beautiful campuses, arts programs, interesting literature, modern technology, field trips, carefree recess, and teachers who know them, I suggest that we create such schools for all children. What’s good for the sons and daughters of the billionaires should be good enough the rest of the children, too.Amending No Child Left Behind won’t fix these problems. Neither will asking the billionaires and businessmen to try to be a little more careful with our children’s education. These solutions filled the void we created with our own apathy and complacency. And we are not powerless to reverse the recent trends and make public schools wondrous learning environments for all children.But in order to achieve such equity of opportunity, parents need to be vigilant and take a stand. Parents can go to back-to-school night this fall. If the science lab contains no equipment, they should demand to know why and not wait patiently while the district hopes they forget. If their first grader was excited about going to school, but by the third day cries hysterically and says, “The teacher hates me,” his concerns should be taken seriously. If their kid’s school is test-obsessed, parents should let teachers and administrators know that they expect more of an education. If every parent was vocally fighting for the best public schools for their children-instead of some of the most involved and caring opting out in disgust-the government would be forced to listen.Because despite their flaws, inequities, and shortcomings, public schools are an American treasure owned by the citizens, and we should treat them as a public trust.

  • Talking turkey! How the Thanksgiving bird got its name (and then lent it to film flops)
    Photo credit: E4C via Getty Images – Not everyone is a fan of Turkey Day.
    ,

    Talking turkey! How the Thanksgiving bird got its name (and then lent it to film flops)

    From Thanksgiving dinner to Hollywood disasters, this bird’s name has quite a history.

    Professor of English, Rutgers University – Newark

    “Meleagris Gallopavo Day” is a bit of a mouthful. Which may be why this Thanksgiving, most people will opt for the less ornithologically precise “Turkey Day.”

    And just as turkey is a versatile meat – think of those leftover options! – so too is the word “turkey,” which can refer to everything from the bird itself to a populous Eurasian country to movie flops.

    As a scholar who studies word origins, I love “talking turkey” – not only how the bird came to be named, but also how the word has evolved over time. But let’s start with what has become the centerpiece of most Thanksgiving Day dinners.

    The North American turkey – the kind that many families will be carving up this Thanksgiving – was being domesticated in Mexico some 2,000 years ago.

    Europeans glimpsed their first turkeys around 1500, when Spanish explorers arrived in the Americas and brought them back to the mother country. By the 1520s, turkeys were being bred in Spain, and soon the delicacy was appearing on rich people’s tables across Europe.

    Oh, dinde!

    But what to call the new import? Europeans in the New World were overwhelmed by the new plants and animals they saw, and often used familiar names for unfamiliar species. The Spanish, for instance, thought turkeys looked like peacocks, so they used the Spanish word “pavos.” The French called them “poules d’Indes,” or Indian chickens, later shortened to “dinde.”

    To the English, the newly discovered American birds looked like the guineafowl – a bird native to Africa but which was introduced into Europe by Arab and Turkish traders in the 14th and 15th centuries.

    And it is this point in the story that the modern-day turkey gets its name.

    The Ottoman Empire was then at its height. Ethnic Turks, based in Constantinople (now Istanbul), ran the empire that spanned the Near East, Middle East and North Africa. As a result, to many Europeans, anyone from “the East” was a “Turk.”

    Because Ottomans dominated trade in the eastern Mediterranean, a lot of produce coming to Europe was seen as “Turkish.” So a precious stone from Persia was named “Turkey stone,” and the French version of that name, “pierre turquoise,” gave us the word “turquoise.”

    In the same way, African guineafowl, introduced by Turkish traders, became a “turkey-cock” or “turkey-hen.” Over time, this was shortened to just “turkey.”

    Now that’s a feast!

    For as long as the New World turkeys have been in Europe, they’ve been featured in celebratory meals. The English word first appears in print in an account of a banquet hosted by politician John Prideaux in 1555: The menu included 38 red deer, 43 pheasants, 50 quince pies, 63 swans, 114 pigeons, 120 rabbits, 840 larks, 325 gallons of Bordeaux wine and “Turkies 2. rated at 4s. a piece.”

    History’s most famous turkey dinner, though, was served in Plymouth Plantation in 1621, as 50 Pilgrims who survived a year of brutal hardship joined 90 Native Americans for a three-day feast. Turkey wasn’t the only dish being served. Writing in his History of Plymouth Plantation, Governor William Bradford noted that Native Americans brought “codd, & bass, & other fish,” and others brought “water foule” and venison. But he was especially impressed with the “great store of wild Turkies.”

    The bird has become so associated with harvest-time celebratory dinners that we’ve been calling Thanksgiving “Turkey Day” since at least 1870.

    Meanwhile, the word has continued to find new uses, showing up with dozens of meanings. In 1839, the Southern Literary Messenger – a magazine edited by Edgar Allen Poe – reported on a new kind of dance, called the “turkey-trot” from its jerking motions.

    In 1920, New York’s Department of Health reported that “Some addicts voluntarily stop taking opiates and ‘suffer it out’ … which in their slang is called taking ‘cold turkey.‘”

    The turkey’s reputation for stupidity prompted other meanings. The legendary gossip columnist Walter Winchell told readers of Vanity Fair in 1927 about some new showbiz slang: “‘A turkey,’” he reported, “is a third rate production.”

    Since then, movies that flop with the critics or at the box office have been called turkeys.

    Another disparaging sense arrived in the 1950s, when turkey became a name for “a stupid, slow, inept, or otherwise worthless person.” That, in turn, probably led to the rise of the “jive turkey,” which first showed up in African American speech in the early 1970s, defined by slang lexicographer Jonathon Green as “an insincere, deceitful, dishonest person.”

    Jive or straight talking?

    And what about “talk turkey”? Well, that can mean quite contradictory things.

    One dictionary from 1859 defines it as “To talk in a silly manner, talk nonsense.” A similar meaning is attached to another turkey-related word, “gobbledygook.”

    Another definition found in the 1889 “Americanisms, Old & New” had “talking turkey” meaning “To use high-sounding words, when plain English would do equally well or better.”

    The most familiar meaning of “talking turkey,” in which it is a stand-in for “straight talk,” is often said to come from a once popular joke. A white man and an American Indian, the story goes, spend a day hunting together and manage to bag a turkey and a somewhat less bountiful buzzard. The devious white man proposes a “heads-I-win-tails-you-lose” division of the spoils. “I’ll take the turkey, and you the buzzard,” he says, “or, if you prefer, you take the buzzard, and I’ll take the turkey.” The frustrated American Indian replies – usually in some version of would-be comic pidgin English – “You talk all buzzard to me, and don’t talk turkey.”

    Those who study word histories are skeptical of stories like this, since most are invented after the fact. More likely, “talk turkey” came from pleasant conversation at Thanksgiving dinner, or maybe negotiations between Native Americans and European colonists over the cost of poultry. Whatever the origin, though, when we “talk turkey,” we’re engaging in the kind of straightforward, honest speech the scheming hunter denied his hunting partner.

    This article originally appeared on The Conversation. You can read it here.

  • Why do I talk in my sleep? A sleep psychologist explains
    Talking in your sleep is more common in children than adults. Cavan Images via Getty Images
    ,

    Why do I talk in my sleep? A sleep psychologist explains

    Your brain can keep chatting after you’ve called it a night.

    Professor of Psychology, Mississippi State University

    Everyone sleeps, but not everyone understands much about sleep. One of my favorite parts of being a sleep psychologist is that when people hear what my job is, they always have tons of questions, like why do we need to sleep? Why do we dream? Do dogs dream? I get that one a lot, and the answer is yes!

    Sometimes people want to chat about their sibling they share a room with who mumbles nonsense out loud all night long. Or maybe they’ve been teased themselves after delivering a complete but one-sided conversation while fully asleep at a slumber party.

    I’ve studied sleep for almost two decades, and I’m still not tired of discussing different aspects of it, especially what are called parasomnias: things your body does or your mind goes through while you’re asleep, such as nightmares, sleepwalking or talking in your sleep. Most are common and completely harmless; they only count as a disorder when they happen so often that they cause real problems.

    What’s happening while you’re asleep

    Sleep is not one single thing; you go through several stages of sleep every night.

    About a quarter of your sleep is what’s called REM sleep, short for rapid eye movement. This is the stage when most dreams, especially the vivid ones, happen.

    Non-REM sleep, which includes the deeper stages of sleep, usually takes up between 75% and 80% of your night. It is an important stage of sleep where your body really throttles down, allowing it to rest and repair itself.

    Doctors refer to these stages all together as your sleep architecture. People go through cycles of these stages roughly every 90 minutes each night. Non-REM sleep makes up more of your sleep right after bedtime, and then REM becomes a higher proportion of sleep in the early morning hours.

    kitten lying on its back asleep with paws up, tucked under a sheet
    Many animal species also need plenty of shut-eye to stay healthy. Waitforlight/Moment via Getty Images

    All mammals, from mice to cats to elephants, appear to sleep in some form or another. Researchers have found sleep is important for many things. When you’re asleep is when a lot of your memories get strengthened so they’ll last long term. Sleep is when growth typically happens in kids, and it is one of the times when your immune system is most active.

    Sleep is an important time for your brain and body to recharge and take care of themselves. Doctors recommend that teens get 8-10 hours of sleep per night, and even more for younger kids: 10-13 hours for little kids ages 3-5, and 9-12 hours for bigger kids ages 6-12.

    Talking out loud while you’re asleep

    Even though someone who is asleep may look pretty much shut down for the night, their brain is not turned off. Different parts of the brain are active doing different things during different parts of the night.

    Scientists think that sleeptalking happens when the parts of the brain responsible for language and speech are active while other parts of the brain that would typically prevent your mouth from physically talking are asleep.

    For the most part, sleeptalking is not even words. Usually it’s mumbles, laughs or whispers. If a sleeptalker does use language, it is most commonly the word “no” – that’s about 5% of all words that are said while asleep. If the sleeptalker is saying words, they’re often questions and sometimes profanity. Rarely are the things sleeptalkers say polite, and often it sounds like they’re having a conflict with someone.

    Sometimes it can sound like the sleeptalker is having a real conversation, pausing to allow the other person to speak – even if there’s no one else in the room. Researchers suspect you might be overhearing one side of a verbal exchange from a sleeptalker’s dream. What a sleeptalker is saying out loud during REM sleep matches what they’re dreaming about at that moment about 80% of the time, according to studies in sleep labs.

    man in bed lifts eye mask and looks quizzically over at woman asleep in eye mask
    A sleeptalker is far more likely to speak gibberish than a real secret. megaflopp/iStock via Getty Images Plus

    You may be able to actually interact with someone who is sleeptalking; researchers have found that roughly half the time a sleeptalker will respond to a spoken question or statement. But don’t get excited that you can get someone to spill their secrets or reveal something they don’t want to. There’s no scientific evidence of this happening.

    There is not a ton of research on sleeptalking yet, but it appears that this phenomenon can happen in any stage of sleep. Studies do suggest there are differences between the sleep of people who sleeptalk and those who don’t. For instance, one study found that sleeptalkers get more than an hour and a half less sleep per night and roughly half as much REM sleep as nonsleeptalkers.

    Why do people talk in their sleep?

    The best explanation we have for sleeptalking is that the brain does not fall asleep all at once, and for some people the areas responsible for sleep remain active longer than the parts that help keep them quiet.

    This phenomenon is fairly common, with over two-thirds of people sleeptalking at one time or another. It isn’t something to be concerned about if it has happened to you, though it does increase your likelihood of experiencing other parasomnias such as sleepwalking.

    Sleeptalking is far more common in childhood. Researchers don’t fully understand why, but we do know that children have more of what’s called slow-wave non-REM sleep. The proportion of slow-wave sleep you have each night declines as you grow older, so it is possible that less sleeptalking comes with this change in sleep architecture.

    Looking at the big picture, sleeptalking is considered normal. But if you’re bothered by it – or by other parasomnias, such as sleepwalking, night terrors or bed-wetting – remember, they all become less common as you grow up. And there are treatments you can get from a sleep psychologist like me.

    One last tip: Scientists do know that sleeptalking, as well as several other parasomnias, is more common when you’re overtired. So, the next time you talk in your sleep, you’ll know that it’s nothing to worry about, but perhaps a sign that you need to catch up on some extra zzz’s when you can.

    This article originally appeared on The Conversation. You can read it here.

  • Too many males to choose from can overwhelm female frogs – and change who gets to mate
    There can be too many frogs in the dating pool. R. Andrew Odum/Photodisc via Getty Images

    Assistant Professor of Ecology & Evolutionary Biology, University of Tennessee; Smithsonian Institution

    If you’ve ever felt overwhelmed by menu options at a restaurant, cereal varieties at the grocery store or potential partners while scrolling through dating apps, you’ve experienced choice overload.

    People aren’t the only ones to have trouble making decisions when confronted with many options simultaneously. In our new study published in the journal iScience, my colleagues and I found similar effects of choice overload in female gray tree frogs when faced with too many calls from males looking for love.

    Scientists have observed many species having similar decision-making problems when experiencing choice overload. But we know little about how these kinds of cognitive constraints affect animals in natural settings.

    Indecision on the frog dating scene

    The gray tree frogs we focused on live in wooded areas near sources of water in North America. During the mating season, males gather in choruses and call to attract mates. Females pick mates based on several call attributes, including call length. Longer calls are more attractive.

    For our experiment, we captured 60 female tree frogs from breeding choruses in East Tennessee and brought them into our lab. Then we played recorded mating calls for each female, giving her a choice between one long, attractive “target” call and one, three or seven shorter, less attractive “distractor” calls.

    In the wild, a tree frog breeding chorus can include dozens or even hundreds of calling males. In our lab setup, the calls played sequentially, so they never overlapped.

    Females would hop toward the speaker broadcasting the call she preferred. As the number of distractor calls increased, females got worse at picking the attractive call, took longer to decide, and were more likely to defer choosing within the 10-minute window altogether.

    Black and white aerial view of a circular area with a white star in the middle
    View from above of the frog test arena, where researchers would place a female frog in the center and then play various male mating calls from speakers placed around the perimeter. Jessie Tanner

    Cognitive confusion

    Because we eliminated call overlap entirely, we know this decline wasn’t due to what researchers call energetic masking. That’s the well-documented problem of overlapping signals impairing an individual’s ability to detect and discriminate a signal from noise.

    Biologists have long known that female preferences can weaken in choruses and have usually assumed the explanation is energetic masking: Too many overlapping signals create a challenge for the frogs’ perceptual systems. In other words, they can’t detect or discriminate individual calls.

    Instead, our study shows that a female’s own cognitive limits can make it hard for her to select her preferred mate. The challenge comes from too many males to choose from, not being unable to hear the males clearly.

    When females can’t make the optimal choice

    Call traits are linked to offspring fitness in gray tree frogs. If females have trouble recognizing the calls they prefer in a real chorus, they aren’t able to pick the mates with the best genes to pass on. They may end up mating with males they would otherwise reject. These males with less going for them then pass on their less desirable traits, which could have negative consequences for the offspring.

    Smaller frog on top of larger frog with grass blades around
    Females’ cognitive overload could be an opportunity for males who might not otherwise get a chance to mate. Jessie Tanner

    Our finding raises the possibility that males could exploit this cognitive limitation in females. Less attractive males might do better by joining bigger choruses, where the sheer number of competitors makes it harder for females to discriminate against them. Conversely, more attractive males may benefit from calling in smaller groups, or even in isolation. My colleagues and I hope to investigate some of these possibilities soon.

    More options, more opportunities … to a point

    We ran our experiments in a simplified lab arena, which allowed us to isolate choice overload from other effects. We removed the real-world clutter of overlapping calls, vegetation and risk from predators that females would face in an actual pond. We also limited female choice to eight calls, though frogs may hear even more in natural settings.

    The next step in this research is figuring out how much choice overload matters in a real chorus, where calls do overlap, and where sensory processing and cognitive processing are probably both at play. We’re particularly interested in seeing whether, in natural choruses, decisions do take longer and females really end up mating with less preferable males.

    Choice overload isn’t unique to frogs, or even to mate choice. Researchers have seen bees choosing among flowers, ants comparing potential nest sites and mosquitoes selecting egg-laying sites all making worse decisions as the number of competing options increases. And recent research on field crickets and tree frogs has found similar patterns in these animals as they pick mates based on their calls.

    Together, this growing body of evidence suggests that cognitive constraints are a general feature of animal decision-making.

    This article originally appeared on The Conversation. You can read it here.

Explore More Stories

Society

I research play – and here’s why recess is much more important than just a fun break

Society

Remote work made these colleagues more open with each other, not less

Society

Dog parks are an antidote to the isolation and divisions that social media can fuel

Health

We paid college students about $5 a night to sleep at least 7 hours – and their grades quickly improved