GOOD.is
GOOD is a collaboration of individuals, businesses, and nonprofits pushing the world forward. Get involved.
  • Home
  • |
  • Columns ▶
    • BoingBoing on GOOD
    • Joe Ippolito on Business
    • Carol Coletta on Cities
    • Alissa Walker on Design
    • Ben Jervey on the Environment
    • Peter Smith on Food
    • Truman National Security Project on Foreign Policy
    • Picture Show
    • Mark Peters on Language
    • Anne Trubek on Literature
    • See All Columns
  • |
  • Video
  • |
  • Infographics
  • |
  • Community
  • |
  • Events
  • Follow GOOD:
  • twitter
  • flickr
  • facebook
  • youtube
  • rss feed
  • Business
  • |
  • Cities
  • |
  • Culture
  • |
  • Design
  • |
  • Education
  • |
  • Environment
  • |
  • Food
  • |
  • Health
  • |
  • Media
  • |
  • People
  • |
  • Politics
  • |
  • Technology
  • |
  • Transportation
  • 1
  • 4

Punk’d: Fine Art Edition

  • Posted by: Andrew Price
  • on April 29, 2008 at 1:39 pm

In “The Tuymans Experiment,” the acclaimed Belgian painter Luc Tuymans and some art-world collaborators punk the plebes. The painter—whose work sells for millions at auction and whose importance is, we’re assured, beyond dispute—paints a mural on a busy Antwerp street. A hidden camera records whether passersby stop to appreciate the work of a master. It’s a thought-provoking video.

We’re all for public art, and the modest Tuymans is a good sport. But, when only 4% of passersby stop, the narrator hopes that “these numbers will wake people up…[to] take more interest in art.” We’re a little uncomfortable with the suggestion that a busy student, or surgeon, or postal worker, is obligated to stop just because a Tuymans painting is there. After all, people routinely walk past entire museums full of art for perfectly good reasons.

Just for fun, we’d be curious to try the opposite experiment: take a painter without critical credentials, put them in a respected gallery, and secretly tape the praise of the aesthetes.

Thanks, Noella.

  • Filed under: Blog : GOOD Blog
  • Categories: Design
  • Share
  • Discuss
  • Mark it good!
  • Facebook
  •   Twitter
  • Digg
  • Stumble
  • del.icio.us
  • Reddit
Direct link to this post:
Send as an Email:
Your email address:
Recipient's email address:
Message:

X
DISCUSSION: 4 Comments
    • Posted by: ZMarker
    • on April 29, 2008 at 7:50 pm

    I remember reading about a very similar experiment with Joshua Bell, a violinist whose importance is, I’m assured, beyond dispute.

    It’s a good way to question the validity of art criticism, but again, has flaws – these people are busy!

    Here’s a write up in the Washington Post about it [url=http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2007/04/04/AR2007040401721.html[/url]

    • Posted by: ZMarker
    • on April 29, 2008 at 7:53 pm

    Here’s the link, hopefully

    • Posted by: shailendra
    • on April 30, 2008 at 11:54 pm

    As for the work of Art , it is to be understood that MASS ART ( POSTER FOR ATTRACTING) and CLASS ART ( An art with meditative , Discursive and converging interactive thought prevocking quality) are diffrent expressions of Art and They appeal to diffrent sets of people . Like people Art has also diversity and multiplicity it camn not be rated in this simplistic manner

    Shailendra Tiwari

    ARTIST

    Bhopal

    http://www.absolutearts.com/portfolios/s/shailendra

    • Posted by: Anonymous
    • on May 22, 2009 at 12:16 pm

    Actually an artist known as Banksy has already placed his (unknown) art in museums.  Some pieces were in the museum for months without anyone knowing any better.

Login or Sign up to discuss this article

Related Content

  • Magazine : Look

    School Colors

    Publicolor replaces drab, institutional school paint jobs with bright colors.
    Read & Discuss

  • Blog : GOOD Blog

    The World's Coolest Bus Stops

    Bus travel in the United States often finds itself the victim of unwarranted negative stigma. But as ...
    Read & Discuss

  • Magazine : The Transportation Issue

    Prettier Buses Get More Rides

    David Mocarski on the art of attracting people to public transit Mocarski and his students are hoping to change ...
    Read & Discuss

  • Blog : GOOD Blog

    Don't Mess With The Post Office

    We swear this is not a re-cap of a Seinfeld episode. A British postman started educating people on his route ...
    Read & Discuss

  • Blog : The Community Board

    Interview with Artist Hilary Pecis

    Spraygraphic Interview with Hilary Pecis SG: Please tell us about yourself? HP: My name Hilary Pecis. 29 years old. I am ...
    Read & Discuss

Recent Readers

  • Aaron Bramley
  • Amrit
  • alanajevert
  • Meghan Christina
  • Will Etling
  • morganclendaniel
  • Price
  • Suncaster
See all

This Week In Blogs

  • Most Discussed
  • Most GOODMarked
  1. Are You Raising a Furkid?
  2. Is Owning a Dog Worse than Owning an SUV?
  3. Is Your Favorite Song a Torture Device?
  4. The GOOD 100: Artificial Photosynthesis
  5. The Language of 30 Rock
  6. Heavenly Fuel from Garbage, Weeds, and Pond Scum
  7. How Many Books Do You Read Each Year?
  8. Is Urban Homesteading Keeping Women Down?
  9. Welcome to the (Recently-rebranded) Neighborhood
  10. Charging Forward with Mission Motor’s Electric Superbike
  1. Charging Forward with Mission Motor’s Electric Superbike
  2. Greener Pastures
  3. A Grassroots Seduction
  4. Advertising, Abstracted
  5. Is Urban Homesteading Keeping Women Down?
  6. LOOK: PACT Sustainable Underwear
  7. Thirty-seven Picture Shows from around the World
  8. Transparency: The Most Homicidal Countries
  9. Picture Show: Inside a Colombian Prison
  10. How Thanksgiving Got Its Turkey

GOOD Magazine
About
|
Join
|
Sign In

Categories

  • Business
  • Cities
  • Culture
  • Design
  • Education
  • Environment
  • Food
  • Health
  • Media
  • People
  • Politics
  • Technology
  • Transportation

Special Features

  • Blogs
  • Events
  • Infographics
  • Look
  • Picture Show
  • Q&A
  • Video

Community

  • Community Board
  • Member directory
  • Join the Community

Social

  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • YouTube
  • Flickr

Magazine

  • Current issue
  • Back issues
  • Subscribe
  • Gift a gift
  • Renew/Service

GOOD

  • What is GOOD?
  • Make GOOD better
© GOOD Worldwide LLC. - all rights reserved
  • Company details
  • Contact
  • Advertise
  • Careers
  • RSS
  • Privacy
  • Terms
  • Powered by Verkata