GOOD.is
GOOD is a collaboration of individuals, businesses, and nonprofits pushing the world forward. Get involved.
  • Home
  • |
  • Columns ▶
    • BoingBoing on GOOD
    • Joe Ippolito on Business
    • Carol Coletta on Cities
    • Alissa Walker on Design
    • Ben Jervey on the Environment
    • Peter Smith on Food
    • Truman National Security Project on Foreign Policy
    • Picture Show
    • Mark Peters on Language
    • Anne Trubek on Literature
    • See All Columns
  • |
  • Video
  • |
  • Infographics
  • |
  • Community
  • |
  • Events
  • Follow GOOD:
  • twitter
  • flickr
  • facebook
  • youtube
  • rss feed
  • Business
  • |
  • Cities
  • |
  • Culture
  • |
  • Design
  • |
  • Education
  • |
  • Environment
  • |
  • Food
  • |
  • Health
  • |
  • Media
  • |
  • People
  • |
  • Politics
  • |
  • Technology
  • |
  • Transportation
  • 3
  • 17

Fast Food Is Why You’re Fat

  • Posted by: Patrick James
  • on May 6, 2009 at 3:36 pm

Painfully obvious? Yes. But Catherine Rampbell has a graph to back it up. It looks like there’s a pretty real correlation between the time people in various countries spend eating and the rate of obesity in that country. That is, the more time people spend eating, the lower the rate of obesity. There’s a slow food endorsement if I’ve ever seen one.

Via Marginal Revolution.

  • Filed under: Blog : GOOD Blog
  • Share
  • Discuss
  • Mark it good!
  • Facebook
  •   Twitter
  • Digg
  • Stumble
  • del.icio.us
  • Reddit
Direct link to this post:
Send as an Email:
Your email address:
Recipient's email address:
Message:

X
DISCUSSION: 17 Comments
    • Posted by: jlevy
    • on May 6, 2009 at 4:23 pm

    I want to move to Turkey!

    • Posted by: Andrew Price
    • on May 6, 2009 at 4:42 pm

    Is part of this effect just coincidence? Some countries with cultural traditions of long meals (France, Italy) also happen to have pretty healthy diets.

    • Posted by: Moebius
    • on May 6, 2009 at 4:47 pm

    I’m not sure I believe this.  I believe it’s the content of the food (saturated fat, carbs, etc) that cause us to be obese.  I can spend all day eating vegetables and someone else can spend all day eating cheeseburgers and who do you think is going to be obese at the end of that day?

    • Posted by: ademkader
    • on May 6, 2009 at 6:22 pm

    @jlevy turkey welcomes you with open arms :)

    • Posted by: Anonymous
    • on May 6, 2009 at 6:56 pm

    I would not be surprised if the correlation factor is only 20%… there are other factors driving the BMI.Could it be the quality of the food?  In the US, food contains a lot preservatives and corn byproducts, even the meat we eat.  Other countries eat a more natural diet.  Could that also drive another 30% correlation? hmmThe portion size?  In the US, food is served in HUGE portions.  Super size the food, the soda, the fries.  DAMN.  You go to other countries and they eat 1/3 of what we eat.  Could that also drive another 30% correlation? hmmEducation in food?  In the US, many are nutritionally illiterate.  We feed our babies formula.  Feed our children Chef boyardee and coke.  Feed ourselves Big Mac, fries & soda… then wonder why many are diabetic and overweight.  Could that also drive another 20% correlation? hmm

    • Posted by: Anonymous
    • on May 6, 2009 at 11:27 pm

    Gotta love the USA/Canada divide.

    • Posted by: Anonymous
    • on May 6, 2009 at 11:28 pm

    That correlation is practically non-existant.  To check, I re-plotted their data and did a logarithmic fit, producing a graph that looks almost identical.  When you measure how well the line fits, using the coefficient of determination (r-squared) value, the value is 0.18 (on a scale of 0 to 1).  That’s a horrible fit, and drawing any conclusions from this scattered graph is a terrible idea.  More details and my graph can be found here:http://www.chrisamiller.com/blog/2009/05/06/bad-graphs-and-bad-reporting/

    • Posted by: Anonymous
    • on May 7, 2009 at 12:52 am

    Very poor correlation. NZers aren’t getting much benefit from spending a lot more time eating than us Aussies.

    • Posted by: carloberg
    • on May 7, 2009 at 11:20 am

    This is pretty questionable.  As some above have already stated, the line is not a great fit.  Further, if you were to drop US and Mexico from the data, the line would approach a flat line.

    • Posted by: Anonymous
    • on May 7, 2009 at 11:27 am

    R^2 of 18%… I was close with my eye balling it at 20% on my May 6, 2009 at 6:56 pm post :-) Here is another reason why the R^2 is low.Time spent eating = f(quality of food, portion size, rate of food eaten)To get a better correlation, nix the Time spent eating and use:Obesity rate = (food quality, portion size, time spent exercising)Food quality – include amount of corn fructose.  That crap is nasty.  Fats, sugar, etc..Portion size – self explanatoryTime spent exercising – include exercise, walking versus driving and jobs that require you to move around a lot)You will get a MUCH better R^2 factor.Sincerely, no 1 important.

    • Posted by: Karen.J.Levy
    • on May 7, 2009 at 7:49 pm

    “Fast Food is Why You’re Fat.”  There is so much misinformation on this subject and it has been poorly studied.  Fast food is one of the factors in weight gain.  Overweight people should stay away from fast food like the plague.  The reason some people in other countries could be eating more if that is the case as this article states, is because what they are eating may not be too life sustaining.  If they are eating a diet of rice or noodles only, they are starving.  This is one way that you can over eat and not gain weight because there is nothing in rice, noodles or tofu.  So it is not the amount you are eating but what you put in your mouth that can make you fat.  But I don’t really mean to use the word, “you” because we are not all fat.  And I know that doesn’t mean that the skinny people have stayed away from McDonald’s hamburgers is how they’ve managed to stay slim.  When I was young, I could eat whatever I wanted and how much I wanted and stay 98 lbs.  Now that I’m middle aged, I can only maintain the weight I have by staying away from fast foods and other high cholesterol meats or control their portion sizes.  I am now twice the weight I was then.  A thing happens to us fat people only.  When we diet, we lose the weight.  But when we go off, we not only gain back the weight but more of it.  It’s like the condition is being aggravated by depriving our bodies.  Studies have shown that in primitive man, it may have been a survival mechanism built in our bodies to ward off starvation.  We have been reduced to a controversial guessing game among us what causes this problem because the problem has not really been studied very well by real scientific research.

    • Posted by: uniqueinvest
    • on May 9, 2009 at 2:08 am

    Fast foods is a automatic weight gain…. It’s a fact… Been there done that. Stop eating fast foods many moons ago.

    • Posted by: Anonymous
    • on May 9, 2009 at 3:48 am

    http://www.8asians.com/2009/03/17/asian-bmi-how-i-became-obese-in-10-seconds/–not to mention that bmi makes bodybuilders seem obese– why not go by body fat percentage, or fat-free mass?  bmi is too controversial to be taken to heart.

    • Posted by: Anonymous
    • on May 12, 2009 at 3:45 am

    Hey anonymous with all the fancy numbers, correlations, formulas, ect. . .. You are an idiot! If you were half as intelligent as you claim, you would jump off a bridge and safe the planet

    • Posted by: Anonymous
    • on May 12, 2009 at 4:23 pm

    “SAFE” THE PLANET? PERHAPS YOU WERE LOOKING FOR SAVE, IDIOT.

    • Posted by: Anonymous
    • on May 13, 2009 at 2:57 am

    Who cares! If someone chooses to be a fat pig let them. Its not like they are going to eat you:)

    • Posted by: Anonymous
    • on May 13, 2009 at 2:52 pm

    The reason why Americans are fatter than other nations has to do more than with fast food.  Americans move the least of all nations.  They drive from their air-conditioned homes to their air-conditioned garages, where they take the elevator to their offices.  They sit in their chair most of the day, only standing up to go to the washroom.  Then they reverse to process to go home.  It is the utter lack of action that, combined with fast food has made American fatter than most others.

Login or Sign up to discuss this article

Related Content

  • Blog : GOOD Blog

    Fast Food Is Why You're Rich

    We posted earlier about a chart showing that people in countries who take ...
    Read & Discuss

  • Magazine : Transparency

    Transparency: The Effects of Bike Commuting on Obesity

    The average American is both overweight and spends more than ...
    Read & Discuss

  • Blog : Borborygmi

    The Big Mac Index

    The Economist just published its report on global Big Mac prices. What is it supposed to teach us? In ...
    Read & Discuss

  • Blog : GOOD Blog

    Food Kills More People than Smoking and Alcohol

    Dr. Jay Parkinson, who you may remember from issue 13, thinks we need to stop pussyfooting ...
    Read & Discuss

  • Blog : GOOD Blog

    Red Meat Is Bad for the Environment: The Chart

    The Oil Drum has an excellent post on Ecological Economics and the Food System. It's packed with interesting ...
    Read & Discuss

Recent Readers

  • patrickjames
  • JJSanDiego12
  • The Hollinator
  • rpm100
  • Amrit
  • guybingley
  • britthinch
  • spottedmankee
  • jgarber623
  • Aisalyn
  • patck
  • emart
See all

This Week In Blogs

  • Most Discussed
  • Most GOODMarked
  1. How Thanksgiving Got Its Turkey
  2. Is Newsweek’s Sarah Palin Cover Sexist?
  3. Transparency: The Effects of Bike Commuting on Obesity
  4. Prison and College: California’s Ridiculous Priorities
  5. Are You Raising a Furkid?
  6. The GOOD 100: Cowpooling
  7. Sad or Cute: Hermit Crab Makes Home in Broken Bottle
  8. The Charter for Compassion
  9. Tips on How to Reduce Food Packaging Waste
  10. New School: How the Web Liberalized Liberal Arts Education
  1. The Charter for Compassion
  2. New School: How the Web Liberalized Liberal Arts Education
  3. The GOOD Guide to COP15: The Fire this Time: Copenhagen and the War for the Future
  4. Singularity 101: What Is the Singularity?
  5. Picture Show: Breach
  6. Intermission: Eye-popping 3D Building Projections
  7. Charging Forward with Mission Motor’s Electric Superbike
  8. EyeWriter: Paralyzed Artist Draws with His Eyes
  9. Tips on How to Reduce Food Packaging Waste
  10. Prison and College: California’s Ridiculous Priorities

GOOD Magazine
About
|
Join
|
Sign In

Categories

  • Business
  • Cities
  • Culture
  • Design
  • Education
  • Environment
  • Food
  • Health
  • Media
  • People
  • Politics
  • Technology
  • Transportation

Special Features

  • Blogs
  • Events
  • Infographics
  • Look
  • Picture Show
  • Q&A
  • Video

Community

  • Community Board
  • Member directory
  • Join the Community

Social

  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • YouTube
  • Flickr

Magazine

  • Current issue
  • Back issues
  • Subscribe
  • Gift a gift
  • Renew/Service

GOOD

  • What is GOOD?
  • Make GOOD better
© GOOD Worldwide LLC. - all rights reserved
  • Company details
  • Contact
  • Advertise
  • Careers
  • RSS
  • Privacy
  • Terms
  • Powered by Verkata