GOOD.is
GOOD is a collaboration of individuals, businesses, and nonprofits pushing the world forward. Get involved.
  • Home
  • |
  • Columns ▶
    • BoingBoing on GOOD
    • Joe Ippolito on Business
    • Carol Coletta on Cities
    • Alissa Walker on Design
    • Ben Jervey on the Environment
    • Peter Smith on Food
    • Truman National Security Project on Foreign Policy
    • Picture Show
    • Mark Peters on Language
    • Anne Trubek on Literature
    • See All Columns
  • |
  • Video
  • |
  • Infographics
  • |
  • Community
  • |
  • Events
  • Follow GOOD:
  • twitter
  • flickr
  • facebook
  • youtube
  • rss feed
  • Business
  • |
  • Cities
  • |
  • Culture
  • |
  • Design
  • |
  • Education
  • |
  • Environment
  • |
  • Food
  • |
  • Health
  • |
  • Media
  • |
  • People
  • |
  • Politics
  • |
  • Technology
  • |
  • Transportation
  • 16
  • 5

Paper not Plastic

  • Posted by: coreybinns , GrantDelin
  • on May 28, 2007 at 9:24 pm

Ross Mirkarimi has found an easy way to lessen global warming, our dependence on foreign oil, and rapidly overflowing landfills. The solution is in the bag—literally. Each of our featherweight plastic shopping bags carries a hefty cost: Americans use 100 billion plastic bags each year, and toss the majority of them after a quick trip to the store. Since the bags take nearly a millennium to break down in landfills, they’ll be haunting the planet long after we tote home the groceries. Today, local governments pay to have wind-blown bags plucked from trees and telephone wires; in San Francisco, cleanup efforts run as high as $8 million a year. Plus, more than a million sea birds and a hundred thousand marine mammals suffocate from plastic litter each year. “Long before I was elected,” Mirkarimi says, “I’ve thought the plastic bag was emblematic of what our country and planet have been suffering from.”

Last spring, Mirkarimi began efforts to make the bag a historical relic. The 45-year-old member of San Francisco’s Board of Supervisors authored legislation that bans plastic bags made of petroleum products from checkout counters at large supermarkets and pharmacies. “Banning a plastic bag is just a good first, small start,” says Mirkarimi, a co-founder of California’s Green Party. He estimates that the plastic prohibition will save 450,000 gallons of oil and prevent 1,400 tons of trash from ending up in a landfill annually.

Quote:
The plastic bag was emblematic of what our country and planet have been suffering from.

Despite having (almost) weaned himself from plastic bags, the city legislator admits they can come in handy on walks with his dog. For those particular occasions, Mirkarimi is eagerly awaiting the introduction of durable, biodegradable alternatives at grocery stores in October, when the law takes effect. The law, signed by San Francisco Mayor Gavin Newsom on the eve of Earth Day, also promotes using recycled paper and cloth bags.

Mirkarimi was elected in 2004 to San Francisco’s Board of Supervisors as the representative of District 5, which includes the country’s oldest Japantown and the famously curvaceous Lombard Street, and his work has repercussions that extend far beyond the boundaries of his district. In our consumptive society, he says, too often we don’t think about the consequences of our choices, whether it be toting shopping bags or filling up at the gas station. “We need to make our economy more soulful,” says Mirkarimi, who holds master’s degrees in both environmental science and economics.

San Francisco is the first city in the country to ban plastic bags, but officials in New York, Texas, Iowa, and elsewhere in California are quickly following in Mirkarimi’s footsteps. He hopes plastic bags are just the beginning. “We can make great change at the municipal level, but we have to be bold about it. We cannot wilt in the face of criticism that we’re out of our jurisdiction,” he says. “These are such critical times, we can’t wait for our federal and state leaders to do the right thing. We’re all on the clock.”

  • Filed under: Magazine : Portraits
  • Categories: Environment
  • Share
  • Discuss
  • Mark it good!
  • Facebook
  •   Twitter
  • Digg
  • Stumble
  • del.icio.us
  • Reddit
Direct link to this post:
Send as an Email:
Your email address:
Recipient's email address:
Message:

X
DISCUSSION: 5 Comments
    • Posted by: rhennesy
    • on June 19, 2007 at 10:43 am

    i am glad that there are people in politics who are trying to make a difference environmentally. It seems so often you hear about the individual citizen trying to make a difference, and that is good, and i applaud it, but the truth of the matter is that the general population is lazy and apathetic, myself not excluded. i feel as though a great deal more will be accomplished when we start creating legislature that requires change in behavior.

    This is an excellent start.

    • Posted by: rcalnan
    • on August 2, 2007 at 3:48 pm

    Similar legislation is happening in Los Angeles, under the title Renew LA. Check it out for great ideas on the city’s efforts to eliminate landfills in the future.

    • Posted by: trailwriter
    • on August 9, 2007 at 7:52 pm

    I found this article interesting and a good idea in theory, but I wonder if all the numbers have been figured to calculate the environmental impact of using another source en lieu of plastic bags. NPR’s Science Friday did a snippet on this type of conservation effort in Ireland (I believe it was Ireland) and they found that more energy was used to transport the nonplastic bags because not as many fit in a truck; also, people ended up buying more garbage bags since they no longer had the smaller plastic bags to reuse for waste.

    I try to ask for paper when it is possible, but I feel that I do reuse the plastic bags for transporting of goods that may leak in my backpack; tying groceries to my bike frame if it is a quick run to the store; reusing for garbage waste and lining trash bins. It would be a shame if my state of Iowa would adopt a no plastic rule without weighing the environmental impact of the replacement bag. Sometimes educating the public to reuse and recycle may just be better than mass change without the research.

    • Posted by: aneles
    • on August 14, 2007 at 1:16 am

    I think the goods outweigh the bads here! The absence of plastic bags will force consumers to think about other options – most notably, bringing their own shopping bag along. I always do, and have surely saved thousands of bags – think of that multiplied by a whole city.

    Lots of societies don’t automatically include a plastic bag for your purchases. In some it’s expected that you’ll bring your own tote. In Korea, for example, bags are not automatically given – you have to PAY an extra five or ten cents for one.

    • Posted by: amateur6
    • on August 15, 2007 at 11:44 am

    Trailwriter is correct. Want to make an actual impact? Ban bag distribution at the store level. Grocery stores in England, even as recently as the mid-80s, didn’t provide any bags — quite a shock to me as an American visitor buying groceries! But I quickly bought a carrier bag and brought it with me, every time.

    From MSNBC: “— Paper bags generate 70 percent more air pollutants and 50 times more water pollutants than plastic bags.

    — 2,000 plastic bags weigh 30 pounds, 2,000 paper bags weigh 280 pounds. The latter takes up a lot more landfill space.

    — It takes 91 percent less energy to recycle a pound of plastic than it takes to recycle a pound of paper. It takes more than four times as much energy to manufacture a paper bag as it does to manufacture a plastic bag.”

    The idea of swapping plastic for paper is a typical knee-jerk reaction that doesn’t come down on the green side of the equation.

Login or Sign up to discuss this article

About The Contributors

  • Corey Binns

    coreybinns

     
  • Grant Delin

    GrantDelin

     

Recent Readers

  • Will Etling
See all

Related Content

  • Blog : GOOD Blog

    Paper, Plastic Or Veggie-Based Bioplastic?

    There's been a torrent of information and opinion recently about how you should transport your groceries. To us it ...
    Read & Discuss

  • Blog : GOOD Blog

    South Australia Totally Bans Single-use Plastic Bags

    For the past four months, shoppers in South Australia have been encouraged to bring their own bags ...
    Read & Discuss

  • Blog : GOOD Blog

    Hold The Bag

    San Francisco has approved a ban on plastic grocery bags in supermarkets. Well, actually you'll still be ...
    Read & Discuss

  • Blog : GOOD Blog

    Who Funds Change?

    San Francisco politician Ross Mirkarimi, who worked to ban plastic bags in his city, says that municipalities must lead the ...
    Read & Discuss

  • Blog : GOOD Blog

    Forget Recycling, Save Time with Precycling

      Although recycling is crucial to the future of our planet, it still contributes to pollution. Recycled waste builds ...
    Read & Discuss

This Week In Magazine

  • Most Discussed
  • Most GOODMarked
  1. Philanthrocapital Gains
  2. The GOOD 100: Artificial Photosynthesis
  3. Picture Show: The Harvest
  4. Digital World Explorer
  5. Greener Pastures
  6. AYM ’09: Moldova’s “Twitter Revolution”
  7. Stop Teaching Handwriting
  8. Picture Show: Inside a Colombian Prison
  9. The GOOD 100: Dambisa Moyo
  10. The GOOD 100: BigBelly Solar Compactors
  1. Greener Pastures
  2. LOOK: PACT Sustainable Underwear
  3. Transparency: The Most Homicidal Countries
  4. Picture Show: Inside a Colombian Prison
  5. Philanthrocapital Gains
  6. Real World Studio
  7. The GOOD 100: Project M
  8. Carpooling Quietly Booms in San Francisco
  9. Transparency: Biking to Work
  10. AYM ’09: Moldova’s “Twitter Revolution”

GOOD Magazine
About
|
Join
|
Sign In

Categories

  • Business
  • Cities
  • Culture
  • Design
  • Education
  • Environment
  • Food
  • Health
  • Media
  • People
  • Politics
  • Technology
  • Transportation

Special Features

  • Blogs
  • Events
  • Infographics
  • Look
  • Picture Show
  • Q&A
  • Video

Community

  • Community Board
  • Member directory
  • Join the Community

Social

  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • YouTube
  • Flickr

Magazine

  • Current issue
  • Back issues
  • Subscribe
  • Gift a gift
  • Renew/Service

GOOD

  • What is GOOD?
  • Make GOOD better
© GOOD Worldwide LLC. - all rights reserved
  • Company details
  • Contact
  • Advertise
  • Careers
  • RSS
  • Privacy
  • Terms
  • Powered by Verkata