GOOD

Is Our Education System Really That Bad?

New Yorker writer Dean Nicholas Lemann put reformers on shout, saying we're overblowing the problems with our education system.


\n
New Yorker writer and Columbia Journalism School Dean Nicholas Lemann is no stranger to calling B.S. In 2006, he poo pooed the idea of citizen journalism (and the greater idea of blogging) as a substitute for traditional journalism. Now, he's put education reformers on shout, saying that two new books, the documentary Waiting for Superman—which opens this week—and the greater save our school system movement is "overblown."

His reasoning with regards to K-12 seems rather elegant:

It should raise questions when an enormous, complicated realm of life takes on the characteristics of a stock drama. In the current school-reform story, there is a reliable villain, in the form of the teachers’ unions, and a familiar set of heroes, including Geoffrey Canada, of Harlem Children’s Zone; Wendy Kopp, of Teach for America, the Knowledge Is Power Program; and Michele Rhee, the superintendent of schools in Washington, D.C. And there is a clear answer to the problem—charter schools. The details of this story are accurate, but they are fitted together too neatly and are made to imply too much.
\n
It is a very tight story, isn't it?
The real problem—or at least a more honest one—Lemann states, is not that our entire education system is in tatters, but that it's still fraught with inequalities that affect minority and low income students. I agree that's the most pressing issue in education, but I'd also note that there aren't a whole lot of charter schools opening in high income, low minority areas. If charter schools are a supposed panacea for what ails our education system—and that's by no means the case—the disease they are most conspicuously targeting is the achievement gap.
Further, he says that, "Measures of how much American students are learning—compared to the past, and compared to students in other countries—are holding steady, for the most part, even as more people are going to school." He's right to note that the fact that increased access to education hasn't led to an enormous drop in its effectiveness, but in order to compete in the new global world, we'd probably want our kids to be better than 17th in science and 24th in math. Another nice goal would be to graduate a higher percentage of students from college, especially since we keep sending more of them on to higher education—an example of a stat that refutes Lemann's claim since it implies our high schools aren't preparing students for the next level.
Lemann may be missing one huge advantage to the fire and brimstone take on our schools: The current, tidy education narrative, while deceptively simple, may also be a marketing ploy.
As mentioned in the Los Angeles Times' first story on teacher effectiveness, ineffective teachers—at least, according to the Times' value-added methodology—are spread throughout the system. So, scapegoating teachers alone doesn't get at why minority and low income students get the shaft in our education system. But, making an issue about the unfortunate few—whether it be those without health care or gay people who can't marry—isn't always the best way to spur people to action. What Waiting for Superman and many other parts of the education reform movement do is put the onus on all adults—from parents to teacher, politicians to administrators.
Sharing the burden, even if it's via an imprecise narrative, might be the best way to get people involved—and to lift all boats.
Photo via David L. Ryan for the Boston Globe.\n
Articles
Julian Meehan

Young leaders from around the world are gathering at the United Nations Headquarters in New York Saturday to address arguably the most urgent issue of our time. The Youth Climate Summit comes on the heels of an international strike spearheaded by Greta Thunberg, the 16-year-old climate activist from Sweden, who arrived in New York via emissions-free sailboat earlier this month.

Translated from Swedish, "berg" means "mountain," so it may feel fated that a young woman with Viking blood in her veins and summit in her name would be at the helm. But let's go out on a limb and presume Thunberg, in keeping with most activists, would chafe at the notion of pre-ordained "destiny," and rightly so. Destiny is passive — it happens to you. It's also egomaniacal. Change, on the other hand, is active; you have to fight. And it is humble. "We need to get angry and understand what is at stake," Thunberg declared. "And then we need to transform that anger into action."

This new generation of activists' most pernicious enemy is denial. The people in charge — complacent politicians and corporation heads who grossly benefit from maintaining the status quo — are buffered from real-life consequences of climate change. But millions of people don't share that privilege. For them, climate change isn't an abstract concept, but a daily state of emergency, whether it comes in the form of "prolonged drought in sub-Saharan Africa…devastating tropical storms sweeping across Southeast Asia, the Caribbean and the Pacific…[or] heatwaves and wildfires," as Amnesty International reportsare all too real problems people are facing on a regular basis.

RELATED: Greta Thunberg urges people to turn to nature to combat climate change

Keep Reading Show less
The Planet

Millions of people in over 150 countries across the globe marched for lawmakers and corporations to take action to help stop climate change on Friday, September 20.

The Climate Strikes were organized by children around the world as an extension of the of the "Fridays for Future" campaign. Students have been walking out of classrooms on Fridays to speak out about political inaction surrounding the climate crisis.

"We need to act right now to stop burning fossil fuels and ensure a rapid energy revolution with equity, reparations and climate justice at its heart," organizers say.

There's no doubt the visual images from the marches send a powerful message to those on the ground but especially those watching from around the world. GOOD's own Gabriel Reilich was on the scene for the largest of the Climate Strikes. Here are 18 of the best signs from the Climate Strike march in New York City.

Keep Reading Show less

September 20th marks the beginning of a pivotal push for the future of our planet. The Global Climate Strike will set the stage for the United Nations Climate Action Summit, where more than 60 nations are expected to build upon their commitment to 2015's Paris Agreement for combating climate change.

Millions of people are expected to take part in an estimated 4,000 events across 130 countries.

Keep Reading Show less
The Planet
via Apple

When the iPhone 11 debuted on September 10, it was met with less enthusiasm than the usual iPhone release. A lot of techies are holding off purchasing the latest gadget until Apple releases a phone with 5G technology.

Major US phone carriers have yet to build out the infrastructure necessary to provide a consistent 5G experience, so Apple didn't feel it necessary to integrate the technology into its latest iPhone.

A dramatic new feature on the iPhone 11 Pro is its three camera lenses. The three lenses give users the the original wide, plus ultrawide and telephoto options.

Keep Reading Show less
Health
via I love butter / Flickr

We often dismiss our dreams as nonsensical dispatches from the mind while we're deep asleep. But recent research proves that our dreams can definitely affect our waking lives.

People often dream about their significant others and studies show it actually affects how we behave towads them the next day.

"A lot of people don't pay attention to their dreams and are unaware of the impact they have on their state of mind," said Dylan Selterman, psychology lecturer at the University of Maryland, says according to The Huffington Post. "Now we have evidence that there is this association."

Keep Reading Show less
Health