Matthew Kupfer believes that his gift is not a normal cooking book and he has several points to prove it.
Ever since the emergence of AI, there have been many debates regarding its ethical implications. Artificial intelligence has been making advancements in almost every field, and a recent post uploaded on X (previously Twitter) shows that it's even being used to write cookbooks. Journalist Matthew Kupfer (@matthew_kupfer) took to X to show a baffling cookbook he received from his parents on his marriage anniversary.
The tweet read, "This week, my wife and I are celebrating our anniversary. My parents ordered us a very practical, thoughtful gift on Amazon: a crockpot and a crockpot cookbook. We're thrilled. There's just one minor issue - I'm pretty sure the cookbook was written by an AI."
This week, my wife and I are celebrating our anniversary. My parents ordered us a very practical, thoughtful gift on Amazon: a crockpot and a crockpot cookbook.
— Matthew Kupfer (@Matthew_Kupfer) March 19, 2024
We're thrilled. There's just one minor issue: I'm pretty sure the cookbook was written by an AI... 🧵
Kupfer expressed his joy over receiving a cookbook for his anniversary, however, he went on to claim that the content of the culinary book was written by an AI tool. His statements were based on certain observations he made while reading the book. He has also attached threads under his post where he carefully pointed out the odd details of the book. His first thread highlighted what was wrong with the book cover.
Here's the book: "The Complete Crockpot Cookbook for Beginners" for 2024 (gotta keep up with crockpot innovations) by Luisa Florence.
— Matthew Kupfer (@Matthew_Kupfer) March 19, 2024
All looks good — except for 2,000 days, which seems kinda arbitrary and a few to many for one year. But no big deal. pic.twitter.com/1J2NLteDLU
The next thread questioned the human touch in the text written inside the book. Kupfer showed his viewers the definition of crockpot inscribed inside the book. He claimed that the text does not have a human touch, indicating that it might have been generated by AI.
But then you open the book and it doesn't seem like it's... written by a human.
— Matthew Kupfer (@Matthew_Kupfer) March 19, 2024
"What is Crock pot?" it asks.
"This electrical cooking equipment is used to make meals, particularly when you want to leave your cooking uncontrolled for hours."
Sadly, I always cook uncontrolled. pic.twitter.com/HMhIB47v9D
Kupfer then pointed out that the book was written in "stilted English," meaning that the tone is too formal and feels incredibly hard to read. His third thread focused on an excerpt from the book which read, "In the 1940s, when women were required to work in locations that were further away from their homes, it was the first time it was used in the United States."
It has a brief history of the crockpot in stilted English:
— Matthew Kupfer (@Matthew_Kupfer) March 19, 2024
"In the 1940s, when women were required to work in locations that were further away from their homes, it was the first time it was used in the United States..."
Very eusphemistic way of describing WWII, but okay...
Out of all observations, Kupfer felt the most suspect part of the book was its author. Questioning the authenticity of the author, he said, "This got me to wondering about the author, 'Luisa Florence.' I looked her up and, lo and behold, there is hardly a trace of her outside Amazon. Here's her photo. Looks like an AI-generated GAN image to me - note the divergent earrings, weird background and missing left shoulder."
This got me to wondering about the author, "Luisa Florence." I looked her up and, lo and behold, there is hardly a trace of her outside Amazon.
— Matthew Kupfer (@Matthew_Kupfer) March 19, 2024
Here's her photo. Looks like an AI-generated GAN image to me — note the divergent earrings, weird background, & missing left shoulder. pic.twitter.com/czUDawRY6r
Joining Kupfer's experience, plenty of X users commented on the overall authenticity of the book. The majority of the comments pointed out that the book was fake. One user named Victory or Death (@IncognitoMeems) talked about the use of AI in writing books as the comment read:
My chiro has started using AI to "write" books on chiropractic-related subjects like posture improvement. Said he has four for sale on Amazon. I think it's becoming more and more common.
— Victory or Death 🇺🇸 (@IncognitoMeems) March 19, 2024
"Yeah... that instantly vibed as a GAN image to me without even looking for details. I played around a lot with it 5 years ago, saving some good ones in case I needed an anonymous but realistic photo," commented @rabcyr_alt while @6502_ftw added: "Oh man, it’s not even a good one. This immediately sets off 'thispersondoesnotexist' dot com alarms in my brain."