What Colin Kaepernick Can Teach Us About Citizenship

Kaepernick’s message is also critical to understanding and addressing recent environmental hazards and disasters.

Photo by Marcio Jose Sanchez/AP.

THE GOOD NEWS:


The fundamental tenet of Kaepernick’s message — racial injustice and social exclusion — is also critical when it comes to understanding and addressing recent environmental hazards and disasters in the United States.

Colin Kaepernick played in only one NFL game in 2017, yet he made Time magazine’s short list for Person of the Year and GQ named him Citizen of the Year.

Kaepernick started a movement of players kneeling during the U.S. national anthem to call attention to systemic racism and the dehumanization of black lives. His protest reflects a broader statement that many Americans, in particular, black Americans and people of color, do not have equal protections or safe access to even basic services. In short, they are not treated as citizens.

But, along the way, some football fans argued the protest he inspired did not belong within the NFL. Others corrupted his message as anti-American. Some restricted Kaepernick’s argument to one that spoke out solely against police brutality in the black community.

We believe the fundamental tenet of Kaepernick’s message — racial injustice and social exclusion — is also critical when it comes to understanding and addressing recent environmental hazards and disasters in the United States.

The unequal outcomes of environmental harm — for example, why some areas seem so hard hit by storms or droughts while others bounce back quickly — can be better understood when framed within a broader conception of “citizenship.” The many meanings of “citizen” have been a key focus for social scientists throughout history, including Aristotle, Cicero, Rousseau, and Arendt; it has also been a primary focus of our research group at the University of British Columbia, where we work on water governance and access.

Many ways to think about citizenship

According to U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services, citizenship is not bound by race, religion, or status but by the shared values of freedom, liberty, and equality.

In this sense, being an equal citizen means you feel welcomed and safe, that you have a voice in changing the status quo, and that you’re governed by the same set of laws and principles as all other citizens. Any person, from a Daughter of the American Revolution to a newly arrived Syrian refugee, is part of this notion of citizenship.

But this is an idealized vision of citizenship — it is not reality.

Preliminary results from our recent fieldwork in South Africa and Ghana — places where the relatively well-off have no trouble accessing a full range of services while the poor have limited access to drinking water and sanitation — suggest that one’s sense of belonging and inclusion is strongly tied to the ability to access basic environmental services.

Kaepernick’s message can (and should) be extended to recent environmental crises, including in Puerto Rico and Flint, Michigan. This is a broader interpretation of Kaepernick’s message that demands our attention.

Differentiated citizenship in Flint

In making dinner, filling a glass with water or taking a shower, we rarely consider how a faucet is connected to being a citizen. But many people do not enjoy easy access to drinking water, as the case of Flint has so powerfully shown.

In 2014, the town’s water source was changed to the Flint River from the Detroit Water and Sewerage Department. This cost-saving mechanism, combined with inadequate water treatment procedures, exposed mostly Flint’s black residents to lead contamination from their aging pipes.

Residents noticed the difference. Yet their repeated requests to local and state officials were rebuffed until evidence showed the water was dangerous and imperiled the health of thousands, particularly children.

It costs $117,400 a day to provide bottled water and filters to Flint’s residents, yet they still live with serious lead contamination. As do many other U.S. communities.

There is a jarring contrast between Flint and nearby towns that are affluent with a majority white population. While residents of Flint are citizens, they are being excluded from equal benefits and protections.

Our research highlights the often underlying issues of citizenship — protection and belonging — behind environmental problems. If we want to address these crises, we must better understand the root causes.

Citizenship divides our political opinions

Just as mutual strength and support unite a team, citizenship is a common thread that unites Americans — as it does people in all countries. Unfortunately, in the U.S., notions of citizenship have resulted in polarized political debates. Too often, citizenship is treated as a clear-cut issue of who belongs and has the legal status to stay or travel.

President Donald Trump’s border wall and unconstitutional visa bans to keep Muslims out of the U.S. are two clear cases of citizenship as status.

But the in-custody deaths of Freddie Gray and many others, the drinking water crisis in Flint and, most recently, Puerto Rico’s miserly disaster aid after Hurricane Maria serve as examples of a different type of citizenship — one where citizens do not have equal access to protection and justice in their daily lives.

Kaepernick has challenged us to rethink whether these values and rights are held equally across our differences. He has highlighted another way of thinking about citizenship, one that moves away from a strictly legal definition to involve inclusion, belonging, equity, and protection — facets of everyday life.

Rethinking our public policy

Over 3.4 million U.S. citizens live in Puerto Rico. While the damage from Hurricane Maria may exceed $30 billion, Trump made sure to blame Puerto Rico’s “broken infrastructure” and “old electrical grid” for the scale of the island’s suffering and damage.

Trump’s own reasoning suggests that broader forces of social exclusion are at play. Kaepernick’s kneeling can serve to raise awareness of environmental discrimination in Puerto Rico. Even as officials admit that as much as one-third of the island’s citizens do not have access to the power grid, FEMA has announced it is cutting off emergency electricity and water supplies.

The island’s short- and long-term vulnerability highlight the need to ensure that our public policy strives to provide equal access to services and protections for everyone.

Kaepernick and those participating in #TakeaKnee say they love America but wholeheartedly believe the country can do better in upholding the principles of equality and justice ostensibly woven into the U.S. flag.

We hope that as Kaepernick’s message continues, it will extend into everyday facets of inclusion, equal protection, and belonging — from getting a glass of clean water to receiving federal aid following a disaster.

Where Trump’s State of the Union speech touted “merit-based immigration,” the border wall, and the visa lottery system as somehow unrelated to the fear-mongering over immigrants, Kaepernick is pushing us to interrogate what it means to be a citizen.

The ConversationA team supports, welcomes, and respects its members, and society must also strive for this. It’s something to think about during the Super Bowl, especially if during the national anthem NFL players take a knee.

Articles

The Justice Department sent immigration judges a white nationalist blog post

The blog post was from an "anti-immigration hate website."

Attorney General William Barr via Wikimedia Commons

Department of Justice employees were stunned this week when the Executive Office for Immigration Review (EOIR) sent court employees a morning briefing that contained a link to a "news" item on VDare, a white nationalist website.

According to the Southern Poverty Law Center, VDare is an "anti-immigration hate website" that "regularly publishes articles by prominent white nationalists, race scientists and anti-Semites." The website was established in 1999 by its editor Peter Brimelow.

The morning briefing is distributed to all EOIR employees on a daily basis, including all 440 immigration judges across the U.S.

Keep Reading Show less
Politics
via Smithfly.com

"Seventy percent of the Earth is covered with water, now you camp on it!" proudly declares Smithfly on the website for its new camping boat — the Shoal Tent.

Why have we waited so long for camping equipment that actually lets us sleep on the water? Because it's an awful idea, that's why.

Keep Reading Show less
Lifestyle

We've all felt lonely at some point in our lives. It's a human experience as universal as happiness, sadness or even hunger. But there's been a growing trend of studies and other evidence suggesting that Americans, and people in general, are feeling more lonely than ever.

It's easy to blame technology and the way our increasingly online lives have further isolated us from "real" human interactions. The Internet once held seemingly limitless promise for bringing us together but seems to be doing just the opposite.

Except that's apparently not true at all. A major study from Cigna on loneliness found that feelings of isolation and loneliness are on the rise amongst Americans but the numbers are nearly identical amongst those who use social media and those who don't. Perhaps more importantly, the study found five common traits amongst those who don't feel lonely.

Keep Reading Show less
Health

He photographed Nazi atrocities and buried the negatives. The unearthed images are unforgettable.

He risked his life to leave a "historical record of our martyrdom."

via Yad Vashem and Archive of Modern Conflict, 2007

In September 1939, the Nazis invaded Poland. By April 1940, the gates closed on the Lodz Ghetto, the second largest in the country after Warsaw.

Throughout the war, over 210,000 people would be imprisoned in Lodz.

Among those held captive was Henryk Ross. He was a Jewish sports photographer before the Nazi invasion and worked for the the ghetto's Department of Statistics during the war. As part of his official job, he took identification photos of the prisoners and propaganda shots of Lodz' textile and leather factories.

Keep Reading Show less
Communities
WITI Milwaukee

Joey Grundl, a pizza delivery driver for a Domino's Pizza in Waldo, Wisconsin, is being hailed as a hero for noticing a kidnapped woman's subtle cry for help.

The delivery man was sent to a woman's house to deliver a pie when her ex-boyfriend, Dean Hoffman, opened the door. Grundl looked over his shoulder and saw a middle-aged woman with a black eye standing behind Hoffman. She appeared to be mouthing the words: "Call the police."

"I gave him his pizza and then I noticed behind him was his girlfriend," Grundl told WITI Milwaukee. "She pointed to a black eye that was quite visible. She mouthed the words, 'Call the police.'"

Keep Reading Show less
Good News