GOOD

This Game of Thrones-Loving Lawyer Explains Why He’s Seeking a Trial by Combat

Turning to history, a frustrated Staten Island attorney gets creative.

Image by Helayne Seidman. Courtesy of Richard Luthmann.

Late last summer in New York, modern law got a medieval request for judicial relief. Staten Island-based attorney Richard Luthmann, a very serious Game of Thrones fan, petitioned the state Supreme Court in August for a trial by combat. Luthmann wanted to take up sword and shield against Connecticut investors who alleged he had helped a client duck a $500,000 debt the investors felt they were owed.


This week, state Supreme Court Justice Philip G. Minardo ruled in a one-page decision that the case would be resolved without medieval violence. Justice Minardo did, however, agree with Luthmann that, in theory, the court has the power to sanction a trial by combat. Luthmann, his honor still apparently besmirched, filed a notice to appeal the judge’s ruling to a state appellate court.

Luthmann tells GOOD he originally became interested in trial by combat through the Game of Thrones novels and television series. Eventually he began talking with people about whether trial by combat was legal under the federal and state constitutions, and if this was a legitimate way of settling disputes.

Luthmann did some research and found that an argument could be made for legal trial by combat. Outlawed by the British Empire in 1818, trial by combat was never made illegal in the United States or, specifically, in New York, where Luthmann would seek a venue for a legally sanctioned fight.

“If you take some of the legal theories out there, namely the originalist interpretation taken by Scalia and Alito, they basically … say, ‘Look, if the document was what it says in 1776 and it hasn’t been altered since then, then the rights are still there,’” Luthmann explains. “By looking at that argument, I said there is an argument to be made that a trial by judicially sanctioned duel is something that could then be granted, or within the permissible bounds of relief that could be granted by a justice in the state of New York.”

Basically, the argument goes, if trial by combat hasn’t been specifically outlawed under the federal constitution, it’s technically possible for a federal judge to allow it.

Duel between Alexander Hamilton and Aaron Burr. Image via Wikimedia Commons.

After supposing that trial by combat was technically legal, Luthmann researched its practice in the United Kingdom and some German principalities and city-states. He describes how historically, mercenaries who worked for minor lords and dukes would settle disputes by beating each other with what he describes as “baseball bats.”

“The question for me became whether there was a place for application for what I’m doing,” Luthmann says. “I did a lot of reading on the duel between Alexander Hamilton and Aaron Burr, and the reason they went to the dueling grounds on the Heights of Weehawken is because it was outlawed in New York State,” and duels weren’t prosecuted as harshly in New Jersey.

Luthmann’s own petition for trial by combat in New York grew out of the Connecticut investors’ attempt to get $500,000 from a client of his. Unsuccessful in pursuing the client, the investors’ lawyer turned around and sued to get money from Luthmann’s malpractice insurance in Foley v. Luthmann.

“They tried to say that I was the facilitator, that I tried to do this and that,” Luthmann says. “And I said to them, ‘You guys are a bunch of idiots. If I’m that bad of an actor, why didn’t you sue me from the very beginning?’” Luthmann responded by filing a motion to dismiss and using other legal processes to frustrate the plaintiff’s case. Finally, the other side filed a motion to preclude and restrain Luthmann from filing a lawsuit against them.

“I said, ‘If I’m a lawyer and I’m not allowed to file papers, then this is the end of things—we might as well go to trial by combat,” Luthmann says. “We might as well get out the swords and the shields at dawn and settle it that way. I met their absurdity with absurdity in kind.”

Depiction of judicial duel between Marshal Wilhelm von Dornsberg and Theodor Haschenacker in Augsburg in 1409. Image via Wikimedia Commons.

Luthmann says that by the time the British colonies were forming, trial by combat was already being phased out, particularly in Scotland.

“But it was still on the books in that there was an attempt to outlaw trial by combat in the British colonies on the floor of the British Parliament in 1773,” says Luthmann. “The measure was actually defeated, and it was referred to as the firmest pillar of the British constitution—that a man can stake his sacred honor in a battle. So when you read the Declaration of Independence, that we’re bound by our sacred honor, it’s right from that era.”

Luthmann believes there are a whole bunch of laws that could produce similarly peculiar juxtapositions between past and present—stuff that is legally applicable that nobody would expect to be on the books. And Luthmann claims this material can come in handy in lawsuits.

“You can get to your wit’s end in litigation,” Luthmann says. “So, you’ve got to have something in your bag of tricks. I play games sometimes, but that’s what you’re supposed to do, to a certain extent.”

“There was a great lawyer named Samuel Liebowitz. The guy has been dead for 50 years, but he said that if you’re going to be someone who practices law in the courts, you kind of have to know everything—you have to be a student of mankind,” says Luthmann. “You have to know what happened with the baseball game, you have to know what the political topics are, and who is coming into town for concerts, because you never know when something like that is going to help you win a case.”

Articles
via The Howard Stern Show / YouTube

Former Secretary of State, first lady, and winner of the popular vote in the 2016 presidential election, Hillary Clinton, sat own for an epic, two-and-a--half hour interview with Howard Stern on his SiriusXM show Wednesday.

She was there to promote "The Book of Gutsy Women," a book about heroic women co-written with her daughter, Chelsea Clinton.

In the far-reaching conversation, Clinton and the self-proclaimed "King of All Media" and, without a doubt, the best interviewer in America discussed everything from Donald Trump's inauguration to her sexuality.

Keep Reading Show less
Politics
Pixabay

Offering parental leave for new fathers could help close the gender gap, removing the unfair "motherhood penalty" women receive for taking time off after giving birth. However, a new study finds that parental leave also has a pay gap. Men are less likely to take time off, however, when they do, they're more likely to get paid for it.

A survey of 2,966 men and women conducted by New America found that men are more likely to receive paid parental leave. Over half (52%) of fathers had fully paid parental leave, and 14% of fathers had partially paid parental leave. In comparison, 33% of mothers had fully paid parental leave and 19% had partially paid parental leave.

Keep Reading Show less

Bans on plastic bags and straws can only go so far. Using disposable products, like grabbing a plastic fork when you're on the go, can be incredibly convenient. But these items also contribute to our growing plastic problem.

Fortunately, you can cut down on the amount of waste you produce by cutting down on disposable products. And even more fortunately, there are sustainable (and cute) replacements that won't damage the environment.

Coconut bowls


Cocostation

Who says sustainable can't also be stylish? These cute coconut bowls were handmade using reclaimed coconuts, making each piece one of a kind. Not only are they organic and biodegradable, but they're also durable, in case your dinner parties tend to get out of hand. The matching ebony wood spoons were polished with the same coconut oil as the bowls.

Cocostation Set of 2 Vietnamese Coconut Bowls and Spoons, $14.99; at Amazon

Solar powered phone charger

Dizaul

Why spend time looking around for an outlet when you can just harness the power of the sun? This solar powered phone charger will make sure your phone never dies as long as you can bask in the sun's rays. As an added bonus, this charger was made using eco-friendly silicone rubber. It's win-win all around.

Dizaul Solar Charger, 5000mAh Portable Solar Power Bank, $19.95; at Amazon, $19.95; at Amazon

Herb garden kit

Planter Pro

Put some green in your life with this herb planter. The kit comes with everything you need to get a garden growing, including a moisture meter that helps you determine if your herbs are getting the right amount of food to flourish. All the seeds included are certified to be non-GMO and non-hybrids, meaning you can have fresh, organic herbs right at your fingertips.

Planter Pro's Herb Garden Cedar Planter, $39.00; at Amazonedar Planter, $39.00; at Amazon

Reusable Keurig cups

K & J

Keurig cups are convenient, but they also create a ton of plastic waste. These Keurig-compatible plastic cups are an easy way to cut down on the amount of trash you create without cutting down on your caffeine. Additionally, you won't have to keep on buying K Cups, which means you'll be saving money and the environment.

K&J Reusable Filter Cups, $8.95 for a set of 4,; at Amazon

Low-flow shower head

Speakman

Low-flow water fixtures can cut down your water consumption, which saves you money while also saving one of the Earth's resources. This shower head was designed with a lighter flow in mind, which means you'll be able to cut down on water usage without feeling like you're cutting down on your shower.

Speakman Low Flow Shower Head, $14.58; at Amazon

Bamboo safety razor

Zomchi

Instead of throwing away a disposable razor every time you shave, invest in an eco-friendly, reusable one. This unisex shaver isn't just sustainable, it's also sharp-looking, which means it would make a great gift for the holidays.

Zomchi Safety Razor, $16.99; at Amazon

The Planet