The Constitution in the News: Bills of Attainder

Unlike my colleagues, I do not think that the AIG bonus tax is a good idea. While I think that many AIG executives should be tarred, feathered, and driven from the country, I don't think this should be done with the tax code. Imagine, if you will, a Republican-majority congress saying that married gay couples had to pay a 90 percent tax on their income.Luckily, the drink-cooling saucer of the Senate seems to be taking care of their more hotheaded friends in the House, and Obama has also been reluctant to support the bill, suggesting he may veto it if it comes to his desk.But what if it passes? Lawrence Tribe, a very smart legal scholar and adviser to the Obama campaign thinks that the bill would be found unconstitutional. Historically, the courts have been reluctant to rule on the constitutionality of the tax code, but this law may violate a more important constitutional principle: the ban on bills of attainder.Bills of attainder-specifically prohibited in Article 1, Section 9-are an old-fashioned legal tool used by British Parliament to punish people for crimes without the mess of a trial. Once a bill of attainder (attainder is from the old French for "to convict") was passed against a person, that person lost all civil rights, his/her children lost all rights to inherit property or title, and the Crown was entitled to the property. The person on the wrong end of the bill was usually executed. Bills of attainder were often used to silence those who had committed treason without having to give them a trial in which they could showcase their treasonous ideas. Indeed, many American revolutionaries were slapped with bills of attainder. The last such bill passed by the British Parliament was against the Irish revolutionary Lord Edward FitzGerald in 1798. Chafing against arbitrary use of power by the King, our budding democracy specifically forbade Congress from passing such bills.In the United States, laws that specifically target one person or one group of people have historically been overturned as violating Article 1, Section 9. The most relevant decision remains Cummings v. Missouri, an 1865 case about former Confederate soldiers who weren't allowed to go into certain jobs without first swearing a loyalty oath to the United States. The Supreme Court wrote at the time:"A bill of attainder, is a legislative act which inflicts punishment without judicial trial and includes any legislative act which takes away the life, liberty or property of a particular named or easily ascertainable person or group of persons because the legislature thinks them guilty of conduct which deserves punishment." If that isn't a dead-on description of the AIG bonus bill, I don't know what is. Interestingly, many people thought the Teri Schiavo bill, geared as it was towards one person, fell into this same category. Bills of attainder: Now you know.
via Douglas Muth / Flickr

Sin City is doing something good for its less fortunate citizens as well as those who've broken the law this month. The city of Las Vegas, Nevada will drop any parking ticket fines for those who make a donation to a local food bank.

A parking ticket can cost up to $100 in Las Vegas but the whole thing can be forgiven by bringing in non-perishable food items of equal or greater value to the Parking Services Offices at 500 S. Main Street through December 16.

The program is designed to help the less fortunate during the holidays.

Keep Reading Show less

For more than 20 years. Sen. Susan Collins (R-ME) has served the citizens of Maine in the U.S. Senate. For most of that time, she has enjoyed a hard-fought reputation as a moderate Republican who methodically builds bridges and consensus in an era of political polarization. To millions of political observers, she exemplified the best of post-partisan leadership, finding a "third way" through the static of ideological tribalism.

However, all of that has changed since the election of Donald Trump in 2016. Voters in Maine, particularly those who lean left, have run out of patience with Collins and her seeming refusal to stand up to Trump. That frustration peaked with the nomination of Brett Kavanaugh to the Supreme Court.

Keep Reading Show less
via / Flickr and Dimitri Rodriguez / Flickr

Bernie Sanders' presidential campaign looks to be getting a huge big shot in the arm after it's faced some difficulties over the past few weeks.

Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez, a leading voice in the Democratic parties progressive, Democratic Socialist wing, is expected to endorse Sanders' campaign at the "Bernie's Back" rally in Queens, New York this Saturday.

Fellow member of "the Squad," Ilhan Omar, endorsed him on Wednesday.

Keep Reading Show less
Photo by HAL9001 on Unsplash

The U.K. is trying to reach its goal of net-zero emissions by 2050, but aviation may become the biggest source of greenhouse gas emissions in the U.K. by that same year. A new study commissioned by the Committee on Climate Change (CCC) and conducted at the Imperial College London says that in order for the U.K. to reach its target, aviation can only see a 25% increase, and they've got a very specific recommendation on how to fix it: Curb frequent flyer programs.

Currently, air travel accounts for 2% of global greenhouse gas emissions, however that number is projected to increase for several reasons. There's a growing demand for air travel, yet it's harder to decarbonize aviation. Electric cars are becoming more common. Electric planes, not so much. If things keep on going the way they are, flights in the U.K. should increase by 50%.

Nearly every airline in the world has a frequent flyer program. The programs offer perks, including free flights, if customers get a certain amount of points. According to the study, 70% of all flights from the U.K. are taken by 15% of the population, with many people taking additional (and arguably unnecessary) flights to "maintain their privileged traveler status."

Keep Reading Show less
The Planet