Why Jared Loughner's Mugshot Probably Isn't Creepy Why Jared Loughner's Mugshot Probably Isn't Creepy

Why Jared Loughner's Mugshot Probably Isn't Creepy

by Cord Jefferson

January 15, 2011

Over at Slate, Jack Shafer has called Jared Lee Loughner's clean-shaven, grinning mugshot "the living avatar of evil." Considering that the photo was taken just hours after Loughner allegedly killed six people, one of them a little girl, his smile is a bit discomforting. But menacing and "evil"? Science says not necessarily.

Despite what those "Don't Worry, Be Happy" T-shirts may tell you, the smile is actually a very complex expression. It's used to convey cheer, of course, but remember that smiling can also be used as a defense mechanism in times of distress.

If you'd prefer to ignore the mountains of anecdotal evidence about nervous smiling in tense situations, consider this from Anthony Stocks, chairman of the anthropology department at Idaho State University:

The evolution of smiles is opaque and, as with many evolutionary accounts of social behavior, fraught with just-soism. Among human babies, however, the 'tooth-baring' smile is associated less with friendship than with fright--which, one might argue, is related to the tooth-baring threats of baboons. ... Somehow we seem to have taken the fright-threat sort of smile and extended it to strangers as a presumably friendly smile. Maybe it is not as innocent as it seems.

Other science says that people in the presence of authority figures—say an accused killer surrounded by police—frequently laugh unconsciously at unfunny things in an effort to get into the authority figure's good graces.

None of this is to say that Loughner is definitely not a homicidal maniac laughing at his carnage, of course. But I think what's more likely is that he's just a scared kid who's seeing the end of his whole world in that camera lens.

Recently on GOOD
Sign up to receive the best of GOOD delivered to your inbox each and every weekday
Why Jared Loughner's Mugshot Probably Isn't Creepy