About Us Contact Us Privacy Policy
© GOOD Worldwide Inc. All Rights Reserved.

German train station experiment uncovers a root cause of bias toward immigrants

We can't defeat it until we understand it.

German train station experiment uncovers a root cause of bias toward immigrants
Photo by XVla / Flickr

An ambitious scientific study conducted in Germany shows how discrimination can work on a spectrum. It also shows how anti-Muslim bigotry is affected by how much the target appears to have assimilated into mainstream society.

"It's a common argument, mainly by parties on the right, that immigrants are resistant to integrating," Nicholas Sambanis, a political scientist at the University of Pennsylvania, told the Los Angeles Times.

"They justify conflict and negative attitudes toward immigration and arguments to reduce immigration by referencing these fears that immigrants don't want to integrate," he continued.

To see whether an immigrants perceived adaptation of cultural norms affects the level of discrimination they face, Sambanis and two of his partners conducted a social experiment in 29 train stations that involved over 7,000 bystanders who unwillingly became test subjects.

The results were published in the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences.

The researchers chose Germany because it's known for upholding a strict set of societal norms and also has the largest immigrant population in Europe.

RELATED: A drunk man was filmed harassing an immigrant on their train ride. The woman next to him responded in the most British way.

For the experiment, a man would drop a cup in the train station and a nonwhite woman who appeared to be a Muslim immigrant would ask him to pick it up. This signaled to the bystanders that she "shared their norms and was a civic-minded person," the study's authors wrote.

Shortly after, the woman's phone would ring and a bag of fruit she was holding would rip open, spilling the contents to the floor. After the spill, researchers would document how many bystanders rushed to help the woman.

The researchers changed the scenarios to determine how different variables affected the bystanders' reactions. About half the time, the immigrant woman wouldn't respond to the dropped cup and another researcher would ask the man to pick it up.

In some cases, the immigrant woman would answer her phone in German and other times a foreign language. They also tried different scenarios in which she wore secular clothing or her head was covered by a hijab.

In a different scenario, a white, German women played the role of the fruit-dropper.

RELATED: What this teen wants you to know about the hijab after her dad's text went viral

The results showed that people were more likely to help the woman when she appeared to be more assimilated into German culture.

When the orange-dropper was white and spoke German, bystanders helped her 78.3% of the time, and if the woman was nonwhite and appeared secular (no headscarf, spoke German) she was helped by just about the same percentage of people, 76.4%.

However, if she wore a headscarf, bystanders helped her only 66.3% of the time.

If the Muslim woman asked the man to pick up his trash, bystanders came to her aid 72.9% of the time; when she didn't, bystanders only helped 60.4% of the time.

A white German woman who did nothing to stop the cup-dropping man was helped about as often (73.3%) as the Muslim woman who went out of her way to do some social good.

Therefore, in order to receive the same treatment as the white woman, the Muslim woman had to first prove her social worthiness.

Finally, if the white woman asked the litterbug to pick up his trash, she received the most bystander help — a full 83.9% of the time.

The study clearly shows the unfortunate truth that, in Germany, Muslim people have to jump through an extra hurdle by displaying their social worthiness before the general public will treat them as equals.

However, there is a silver lining to the study.

The better we understand this type of bigotry, the greater opportunity we have to change people's attitudes. Not all discrimination is intentional, so by educating people on how immigrants share a common humanity with ethnic- or religious majority citizens, we can hopefully work to reverse this particular form of anti-immigrant sentiment.

More on

Inside the 2,000 Watt Society - GOOD

Washington, D.C. Offers $12,000 to People Who Move Near Work ...

Building a Future for Rwandan Women, Brick by Brick - GOOD

This Guy Says His Smart Device Could Stop the Next Outbreak ...

Icelandic Company Cancels Its Summer Hunt for the Endangered ...

One Percent Foundation Unleashes Next Generation of ...

Mars 500: Training Astronauts for a Manned Mission to Mars - GOOD

Explore China's Future In 5 Subway Stops - GOOD

Love on the Streets | GOOD

Can Battlestar Galactica Roleplay Boost Political Engagement? The ...

Germany's secret paedophilia experiment

Experimental study on dynamic load magnification factor for ...

Alstoms hydrogen train Coradia iLint first successful run at 80 km/h ...

First Hydrogen-Powered Trains Rolling in Germany

The Effect of Infrastructure on Worker Mobility: Evidence from High ...

Nazis tried to train dogs to talk, read and spell to win WW2 - Telegraph

Facial recognition surveillance test extended at Berlin train station ...

Schienenzeppelin - Wikipedia

Train Experiment Hints at a Way to Reduce Discrimination Against ...

Train station experiment reveals one way to counteract bias against ...

Islamophobia - Wikipedia

Islamophobia: The Causes, Consequences And Why We Should Care

Islamophobia: A Discussion About The Causes And Possible ...

media: causes and strategies to overcome islamophobia

View from abroad: Causes of Islamophobia - Newspaper - DAWN ...

Mogahed discusses causes and societal impacts of Islamophobia

Islamophobia: Understanding Anti-Muslim Sentiment in the West

Identifying and Rectifying the Root Causes of Islamophobia – 2017 ...

What Are the Major Causes of Islamophobia in the West? | HuffPost

Yes, news media bias is very real. And it's harder than ever to separate fact from fiction. - GOOD

The Supreme Court just saved DACA. This one-minute video shows why the decision is so important. - GOOD

More Stories on Good