Your Favorite Public Education Reformer Probably Went to Private School

Many of today's prominent education reformers attended private school. Their policies for public schools are a far cry from that experience.

What do some of the nation's most prominent public education reform advocates—Michelle Rhee, Jeb Bush, Bill Gates, President Obama, and Davis Guggenheim—all have in common? They received their K-12 education at private schools. "In Public School Efforts, a Common Background: Private Education" from this Sunday's New York Times spotlights this phenomenon and raises important questions about the discrepancy between the well rounded education these reformers received at elite private schools like Exeter and Sidwell Friends, and what they recommend for other people's children.

Even the original champions of the well-intentioned 10-year-old No Child Left Behind act, which first put our nation on the road to an education experience dominated by standardized tests, Democatic Sen. Ted Kennedy, President George W. Bush, and House Speaker John Boehner, all attended private schools. The list of schools the NCLB sponsors and the other more current reformers attended is pretty impressive:

  • Cathleen P. Black, (Aquinas Dominican High School, Chicago)
  • Steven Brill (Deerfield Academy, Deerfield, Mass.)
  • John A. Boehner, (Archbishop Moeller High School, Cincinnati)
  • George W. Bush (Phillips Academy, Andover, Mass.)
  • Jeb Bush (Phillips Academy, Andover, Mass.)
  • Arne Duncan (University of Chicago Laboratory School)
  • Chester E. Finn Jr. (Phillips Exeter, Exeter, New Hampshire)
  • Bill Gates (Lakeside School, Seattle)
  • Davis Guggenheim (Sidwell Friends School, Washington, D.C.
  • Senator Judd Gregg, (Phillips Exeter, Exeter, New Hampshire)
  • Edward M. Kennedy, (Milton Academy, Milton, Mass.)
  • David Levin (Riverdale Country School, the Bronx)
  • President Barack Obama (Punahou School, Honolulu)
  • Michelle A. Rhee (Maumee Valley Country Day School, Toledo, Ohio)
  • Mitt Romney (Cranbrook School, Bloomfield Hills, Mich.)
  • Merryll H. Tisch (Ramaz School, Manhattan)
  • \n

At private schools, students are still regularly taught social studies, science, music, art, and foreign languages. Critical thinking and creativity are encouraged and class sizes are kept small. In a particularly stark contrast, when it comes to test prep, President Obama summed up the private school experience at a town hall meeting late last month while talking about his daughter's experience at Sidwell Friends.

"Malia and Sasha, my two daughters, they just recently took a standardized test. But it wasn't a high-stakes test. It wasn't a test where they had to panic. I mean, they didn't even really know that they were going to take it ahead of time. They didn't study for it, they just went ahead and took it. And it was a tool to diagnose where they were strong, where they were weak, and what the teachers needed to emphasize."


That's a far cry from what goes down for everyone else's kids. Nowadays, marquees in front of public schools proudly proclaim, "It's 27 days till state testing!" and some poor custodian has to change that number every single day. Many of these reformers also relentlessly advocate using tests scores to evaluate teachers and punish schools. A Sidwell Friends faculty member recently dismissed such practices, saying, "We don’t tie teacher pay to test scores because we don’t believe them to be a reliable indicator of teacher effectiveness."

Unfortunately, a public school education has long not been, especially for children from low income backgrounds, at the same level of rigor as a private school education. I attended a private school from fourth through eighth grade, and my freshman year at a public high school, even in honors and AP classes, was pretty much a repeat of the previous year. As an educator working in low income communities, I drew heavily on the standard set by my private school experience. Even though my school only required students to produce one written paper a month, my kids had to write a creative five paragraph essay every single week because that's what my private school experience had been. And, instead of teaching the nuts and bolts of grammar and punctuation through endless test prep worksheets—which is what happens in schools now—my students learned those rules through writing.

Although these reformers surely want what's best for children, why doesn't the way they're going about it reflect their own stellar private school experiences, or the private education many of them provide for their children? It has to be possible to change the status quo of public education by drawing on the excellence present in private schools. Too bad it seems like this current crop of reformers doesn't believe it.

photo (cc) via Flickr user Medill DC


Some beauty pageants, like the Miss America competition, have done away with the swimsuit portions of the competitions, thus dipping their toes in the 21st century. Other aspects of beauty pageants remain stuck in the 1950s, and we're not even talking about the whole "judging women mostly on their looks" thing. One beauty pageant winner was disqualified for being a mom, as if you can't be beautiful after you've had a kid. Now she's trying to get the Miss World competition to update their rules.

Veronika Didusenko won the Miss Ukraine pageant in 2018. After four days, she was disqualified because pageant officials found out she was a mom to 5-year-old son Alex, and had been married. Didusenko said she had been aware of Miss World's rule barring mother from competing, but was encouraged to compete anyways by pageant organizers.

Keep Reading Show less

One mystery in our universe is a step closer to being solved. NASA's Parker Solar Probe launched last year to help scientists understand the sun. Now, it has returned its first findings. Four papers were published in the journal Nature detailing the findings of Parker's first two flybys. It's one small step for a solar probe, one giant leap for mankind.

It is astounding that we've advanced to the point where we've managed to build a probe capable of flying within 15 million miles from the surface of the sun, but here we are. Parker can withstand temperatures of up to 2,500 degrees Fahrenheit and travels at 430,000 miles per hour. It's the fastest human-made vehicle, and no other human-made object has been so close to the sun.

Keep Reading Show less
via Sportstreambest / Flickr

Since the mid '90s the phrase "God Forgives, Brothers Don't" has been part of the U.S. Military Academy at West Point's football team's lexicon.

Over the past few years, the team has taken the field flying a black skull-and-crossbones flag with an acronym for the phrase, "GFBD" on the skull's upper lip. Supporters of the team also use it on social media as #GFBD.

Keep Reading Show less