The Pygmalion Effect: Does Calling It a "Failing School" Make It One? The Pygmalion Effect: Does Calling It a "Failing School" Make It One?

The Pygmalion Effect: Does Calling It a "Failing School" Make It One?

by Liz Dwyer

May 21, 2011

Here's the problem: If someone believes you're smart and successful, they're going to treat you that way. And, if you're treated like you're smart and successful, then you're more likely to behave that way. Similarly, our labeling of schools as failures can have the opposite effect. It suggests the teachers and students inside are deficient. It defines the institution as one in decline.

There's a wealth of psychological data that suggests people live up (or down) to the expectations of others, even when those expectations are communicated in subtle ways. It's called the Pygmalion effect, and it has been well documented. A famous 1965 Harvard Study, “Pygmalion in the Classroom,” confirmed that the beliefs teachers have about their students matter. When teachers in the study saw students as failures, sure enough, those kids were more likely to fail. It's not a stretch to think that the same consequence could result from the labeling of schools.

Kosnar writes that he's not sure why there's such a sudden spike—“Did it originate with academics?  Local or national journalists? State or federal policymakers?” he wonders. Regardless of how the term gained currency, when we think about its increased use—and keep in mind these graphs merely measure books, not blogs, magazines, Waiting for Superman, or statements from Arne Duncan—it's reasonable to worry that that prevalence makes failure more likely.

Of course, if a school isn't serving the academic needs of its students, we shouldn't deny reality. But, as Kosnar points out, language is power. Maybe we need a moratorium on describing schools as failing. I don't know exactly what a good replacement would be—calling a school "academically challenged" sounds like a joke—but picking a term that doesn't implicitly doom teachers and students isn't a matter of hypersensitive political correctness; it's a matter of making the institutions less likely to fail.

photo (cc) via The Grio

Recently on GOOD
Sign up to receive the best of GOOD delivered to your inbox each and every weekday
Ted Cruz's old college roommate shares memories of living with candidate: "A huge asshole."
The Pygmalion Effect: Does Calling It a "Failing School" Make It One?